Beyond Meat Inc (NASDAQ: BYND) Q1 2020 Earnings Call Transcript

Beyond Meat Inc (BYND) Q1 2020 earnings call dated May. 05, 2020

Corporate Participants:

Lubi Kutua — Vice President of FP&A and Investor Relations

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Mark J. Nelson — Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer

Analysts:

Ben Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Erica Eiler — Oppenheimer and Company Inc. — Analyst

Steve Strycula — UBS — Analyst

Ken Goldman — J.P. Morgan — Analyst

Alexia Howard — Bernstein Research — Analyst

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Brian Holland — D.A. Davidson and Company — Analyst

Adam Samuelson — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Rob Dickerson — Jefferies — Analyst

John Baumgartner — Wells Fargo — Analyst

Michael Lavery — Piper Sandler — Analyst

Jon Andersen — William Blair — Analyst

Presentation:

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by, and welcome to the Beyond Meat, Inc. 2020 First Quarter Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] I would now like to introduce your host for today’s conference call, Lubi Kutua. You may begin.

Lubi Kutua — Vice President of FP&A and Investor Relations

Thank you. Good afternoon, and welcome to Beyond Meat’s first quarter 2020 earnings conference call and webcast. On today’s call are Ethan Brown, Founder, President, and Chief Executive Officer; and Mark Nelson, Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer. By now, everyone should have access to the company’s first quarter earnings press release and investor presentation filed today after market close.

These documents are available on the investor relations section of Beyond Meat’s website at www.beyondmeat.com. Before we begin, please note that all the financial information presented on today’s call is unaudited. And during the course of this call, management may make forward-looking statements within the meaning of the federal securities laws. These statements are based on management’s current expectations and beliefs and involve risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from those described in these forward-looking statements.

Please refer to today’s press release, the company’s annual report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2019, filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on March 19, 2020, the company’s quarterly report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 28, 2020, to be filed with the SEC and other filings with the SEC for a detailed discussion of the risks that could cause actual results to differ materially from those expressed or implied in any forward-looking statements made today. Please note that on today’s call, management will refer to adjusted EBITDA, which is a non-GAAP financial measure. While the company believes this non-GAAP financial measure provides useful information for investors, the presentation of this information is not intended to be considered in isolation or as a substitute for the financial information presented in accordance with GAAP. Please refer to today’s press release for a reconciliation of adjusted EBITDA to its most comparable measure prepared in accordance with GAAP.

Now I’d like to turn the call over to Ethan Brown, President and Chief Executive Officer of Beyond Meat.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Thank you, Lubi. Good afternoon, everyone. Before discussing our first quarter results, I’d like to comment on the COVID-19 global health crisis. This is a time of extraordinary challenge and sorrow, but one that we can emerge from with insights that can make us stronger as communities, as a country and as a global society.

On behalf of the entire company, I want to extend our deepest sympathies to families around the globe who’ve been affected by the pandemic. We cannot overstate our gratitude and respect for the frontline responders who risk, and in many cases, have given their own lives to care for the sick and help keep the healthy safe. Behind each rise in the global toll, there are cherished and irreplaceable lives that have been lost and countless more impacted, and it’s this context and meaning that must remain front and center as we navigate this global challenge. At Beyond Meat, the health and safety of our team members and their families, and that of our consumers, customers and supply chain partners, is the Number 1 priority.

I am proud of how swiftly our entire organization has responded to the COVID-19 crisis. We have established an internal task force and brought in qualified advisors, including an epidemiologist on the faculty at UCLA to help guide us in planning and the implementation of steps to help minimize the possibility of COVID-19 occurrences within our operations. Consistent with gubernatorial directives, we’ve closed our headquarters and have employees working remotely. Additionally, for any essential activities at our Manhattan Beach Project laboratory, we are strictly limiting the number of employees allowed in the building.

We are prohibiting outside visitors, and we have implemented physical distancing protocols and comprehensive preventative hygienic measures. Likewise, at our manufacturing facilities, we have implemented a series of physical distancing and hygienic practices to support the health and safety of our manufacturing teams and their families. We have also modified our PTO requirements temporarily, so that employees do not have to deduct sick times from their PTO if they’re feeling unwell. Collectively, we believe these actions have been crucial to our thus far successful risk mitigation efforts.

Our task force, which is being led by our Chief People Officer, is monitoring information from the World Health Organization, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the U.S. State Department, among other resources, and we will make necessary adjustments to existing protocols as the situation evolves. We continue to strengthen our supply chain to support business continuity and mitigate risk. We source ingredients from multiple suppliers around the world with our plant-based proteins coming from suppliers in the United States, EU, China and India.

More generally, in addition to having an improved redundant supply chain in majority of our ingredients, we maintain inventory positioned near our manufacturing operations as well as floor stock agreements with many of our vendors. Throughout this dynamic situation, our operations team has shown flexibility in keeping up the demand for our products even as we’ve had a significant shift in demand mix from food service to retail customers. Nevertheless, even with the above considerations and very strict COVID-19 health and safety measures in place, like others in our industry, we are still subject to heightened risk of disruption to our supply chain. Externally, we continue to offer the highest level of support we can to our foodservice and retail customers during this period.

We hope it is clear at this point that we view our customers as partners, and our role as being of service to them as they take their lead from consumers. In this spirit, we are in frequent communication with our quick-serve restaurant partners as they address the significant disruption to their businesses. As has been our consistent refrain, our focus is on the long term, and there are a few things more important in that regard than being a truly supportive partner during periods of instability. Finally, before turning to our first quarter results, I’d like to share some comments on our Feed A Million+ pledge.

In late March, we launched a program to provide more than 1 million Beyond Burgers and nourishing meals at no cost to frontline workers addressing the pandemic as well as to organizations that serve the most economically vulnerable of our society. It has been gratifying to see our broader family go beyond ambassadors as well as friends of the brand spearhead this initiative with us, including, among others, Kyrie Irving, Kevin Hart, Snoop Dogg, Lindsey Vonn, P.K. Subban, Billie Eilish, Karlie Kloss, Jewel, Ludacris, DeAndre Hopkins, Erin Andrews, Ashanti, Todd Gurley and Kenny Stills; each of whom have joined us in giving Beyond Burgers away to frontline workers and those in need, reinforcing a sense of community during this challenge. I’d like to thank each of them along with our entire team from production through to sales and marketing, the strong execution of this initiative across the country.

Now turning to the first quarter. Our results continued to validate the strength of the broader plant-based meat movement and our leadership position therein. We achieved net revenues of $97 million in Q1 2020, an increase of 141% compared to the first quarter last year, despite growth being negatively impacted toward the end of the quarter by the pandemic. Mark will walk you through our financial results in greater detail, including an estimate of the impact of COVID-19-related demand shifts in our foodservice and retail businesses.

However, at a high level, I will share that we began the year with strong momentum across our enterprise, followed by a meaningful slowdown in our foodservice business during the latter half of March as various regions around the world implemented stay-at-home orders. Although we did see a simultaneous boost in sales to retail customers, this was not enough to offset deterioration of demand in our foodservice business. Nevertheless, we believe our dual-pronged approach of aggressively expanding availability of Beyond Meat products in both retail and foodservice outlets served us well and helped to mitigate even more significant COVID-19-related disruptions to our revenues. In U.S. retail, sales of Beyond Meat products were up 190% year-over-year with velocity growth of 158%, contributing to a 770 basis point increase in market share, according to SPINS data for total U.S. multi-outlet, natural and specialty channels for the 12-week period ended March 22, 2020, while the plant-based meat category as a whole was up 54%.

During this period, Beyond Meat continued to own the Top 4 best-selling SKUs in all plant-based meat and outpaced its closest competitor in terms of year-over-year sales growth by a factor of roughly six times. Furthermore, during the four-week period ended March 22, 2020, in which retailers saw stockpiling by consumers as stay-at-home orders proliferated, sales of Beyond Meat products were up 233% year-over-year with velocity growth of 195%, outperforming the plant-based meat category as a whole, which rose 93%.

First quarter 2020 net revenues in our foodservice doubled versus a year ago despite the impact of COVID-19 in late March. This increase was primarily driven by growth in the number of foodservice outlets carrying our products versus a year ago. As in retail, our growth in foodservice outpaced that the category as a whole. According to NPD data for the first quarter of 2020, dollar sales of plant-based meat products to U.S. foodservice locations were up 18.4% on a year-over-year basis, while Beyond Meat’s growth was up 51.9% over the same period.

Reflecting the impact of COVID-19 on the foodservice segment, NPD track sales plant-based meats were down 25% sequentially during the month of March as compared to February 2020. As a reminder, NPD data captures approximately 80% of the U.S. broadline distribution and excludes cash and carry and direct delivery customers.

As such, NPD will not correlate perfectly with our own reported sales to U.S. foodservice customers, but is nonetheless directionally informative. After launching Beyond Breakfast Sausage with Starbucks in Canada in early March, in April, we announced together with Starbucks, our entry into Mainland China. The April 22, 2020 launch of Beyond Beef items at Starbucks throughout China represents an important milestone for Beyond Meat.

It has long been our aspiration to be a global protein company and being of service to the growing demand for high-quality protein in China is a key part of our strategy. We applaud Starbucks for making and acting upon a strong commitment to advance health and sustainability and are pleased to partner with this trusted brand as they seek to tackle that which matters most. We believe the new Beyond Beef items in Starbucks’ menu throughout China deliver on our promise of enabling consumers to eat what you love, while enjoying the nutritional and environmental benefits of plant-based protein.

In addition to our partnership with Starbucks, we finalized a distribution agreement with China with a leading local distributor, Sinodis, to unlock a network of distribution opportunities across retail and foodservice. We have further established a Chinese language website, as well as branded Weibo and WeChat accounts in order to engage with the Chinese consumer and support the brand’s introduction in this important market. We remain committed to our goal of establishing a production footprint in Asia before the end of 2020, having further developments with the COVID-19 pandemic. The magnitude of the opportunity in Asia merits significant investment, and reflecting such recent disruptions in the region’s protein supply due to African swine flu, we are proceeding with a sense of urgency appropriate for the challenge and opportunity alike. As I have often said, at our core, we strive to be an innovation engine, using technology to source the core parts of meat directly from plants, relying on non-GMO, plant-based ingredients.

Even as the size and complexity of our organization grows, we strive to sharpen our innovation capabilities and quicken the pace of the Beyond Meat rapid and relentless innovation program. We are pleased with the initial outputs of our new center of commercialization and believe this cross-functional initiative will, one, further strengthen our ability to rapidly innovate on behalf of our QSR partners; and two, accelerate the rate in which we improve our beef, pork and poultry platforms in pursuit of our true north of plant-based meat that is indistinguishable from its animal protein equivalent. In the marketplace, we launched our Beyond Breakfast Sausage in select retailers across the United States, beginning in late March, previously only available in select QSR partners, including Dunkin’, Hardee’s, Carl’s Jr. and Starbucks Canada.

Beyond Breakfast Sausage offers 11 grams of protein per serving from peas and brown rice, 50% less total fat with 35% less saturated fat and sodium and 33% fewer calories than the leading brand of pork sausage patties. Furthermore, Beyond Breakfast Sausage, which is a certified kosher NOL, is made without GMOs, soy or gluten. And it has no cholesterol, no nitrates or nitrites, no antibiotics, no hormones and no artificial ingredients. These nutritional wins embody what we seek to achieve throughout our products without sacrificing important qualities, such as taste, texture and other sensory attributes of popular animal protein products.

Although we are excited about the prospects of retail roll-out of Beyond Breakfast Sausage, we do anticipate it will be slower than normal given the impact of COVID-19 on retailer operations. Before closing, I want to be as clear as possible with respect to our view on the impact of the current pandemic on our business. It is having and will continue to have a negative impact in the short term. This impact is largely due to the disruption of normal business operations within the foodservice sector.

We can neither predict when or in what form normalcy will resume for our customers in this segment, nor when we’ll see resumption of any expansion plans for our product lines for those QSR customers who are in trial or test phase. For these reasons, we are joining many other companies in the food and beverage industry who are withdrawing guidance until further notice. Nevertheless, we are not idly waiting for circumstances to accommodate our planned growth trajectory. I am proud of how our management team and all of our team members have reacted to this challenging environment.

As the pandemic began to interrupt the world economy, we created offensive and defensive teams across the company to guide our navigation of the changing landscape. Offensive measures include switching foodservice production lines over to retail products, developing value packs for instant retailers and offering aggressive pricing with a strategic opportunity to encourage consumer trials during this period of disruption in the animal protein market. Defensive measures have primarily been focused on trimming discretionary spend and activities in areas where effectiveness has been impeded by the pandemic, for example, certain marketing programs, or delaying until later in the year or until 2021 makes sense under the circumstances. To reiterate a prevailing perspective that runs through Beyond meat, we are only getting started.

Even with our significant traction to date, we represent an exceedingly small fraction of the $1.4 trillion global meat category today. For example, according to our most recent Nielsen panel data, in the U.S., where household penetration stands at slightly less than 4%, and although our products are now available in approximately 94,000 retail and foodservice outlets and in 75 countries worldwide, we have only a small number of SKUs available in retail on limited distribution within many of our foodservice partners and are just scratching the surface within the vast majority of economies we are in globally.

Despite the current disruption, we remain highly optimistic about our long-term growth prospects, and we continue to accomplish milestones along our exciting upward trajectory. We remain focused on the consumer and customer alike, seeking to delight the former while being an exceptional, dedicated service to the latter, thinking and behaving like a long-term partner, who is investing in their success, as well as our own.

For the balance of 2020, you will see us tell our story on health, ingredients and process with content across digital and print media. You’ll see us push forward on global growth and expansion, as evidenced by our recent launch with Starbucks in China, and you’ll see us invest in research and development to advance and expand our product roadmap across beef, pork and poultry platforms, while pursuing long-term fundamental science in pursuit of step-change progress across sensory, nutritional and cost objectives. And we will continue to keep pace on our steady march toward our long-term objective of being able to underprice animal protein in certain product lines. In short and in closing, we remain steadfastly committed to constructing the building blocks today that are necessary to become the global plant-based protein company we envision for tomorrow.

I’d like to now turn the call over to Mark Nelson, our Chief Financial Officer, who’ll walk us through the first quarter financial results in detail.

Mark J. Nelson — Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer

Thank you, Ethan, and good afternoon, everyone. We are pleased with our first quarter financial results, which we achieved amidst an increasingly challenging operating environment due to the COVID-19 global health crisis. Our strong Q1 results largely reflect demand that exceeded our expectations in January and February, followed by softer results in March as we experienced a deterioration in sales to foodservice customers as domestic and international stay-at-home orders became more widespread. However, we did experience a significant boost in retail demand during the quarter as consumers shifted towards more at-home consumption, partially offsetting the deceleration in foodservice sales.

Overall, as Ethan indicated, net revenues in the quarter were $97.1 million, up 141% compared to the first quarter of last year. Growth in net revenues for the first quarter of 2020 was primarily driven by an increase in volumes sold, partially offset by lower net price per pound. Growth in volume sold was driven by expansion in the number of distribution points, both domestically and abroad, higher sales velocities at existing retail customers and contribution from new products introduced subsequent to the first quarter of 2019. Looking at our distribution channels, retail net revenues increased 185%, while foodservice net revenues increased 100% versus the first quarter of 2019. Sales to international customers across retail and foodservice channels represented 25% of our net revenues during the quarter compared to 30% in the prior year period. As a reminder, beginning this quarter, we are now breaking out international separately in our revenue by channel presentation, and we now include sales to our Canadian customers within this international bucket. Additionally, as we mentioned on our last earnings call, we will no longer be reporting a product category breakout between our fresh and frozen platforms beginning with this quarter.

Our fresh or ready-to-cook product platform now represents substantially all of our consolidated net revenues. And as such, we determined that delineating between sales of fresh and frozen products no longer provides additional insight into the company’s results. Gross profit during the first quarter of 2020 was $37.7 million or 38.8% of net revenues compared to $10.8 million or 26.8% of net revenues in the first quarter of 2019. The 1,200 basis point year-over-year improvement in gross margin was primarily due to an increase in the volume of products sold, production yield improvements, direct materials and packaging cost savings, and improvements in direct labor and other variable overhead costs relative to the first quarter of 2019.

The combination of these factors led us to achieve the company’s best ever quarterly cost of goods sold per pound and reinforce our belief in our long-term goal to take cost out of our manufacturing operations and narrow the price gap of our products relative to animal protein. While we are extremely pleased with our strong gross margin performance in Q1 2020, we do expect near-term headwinds at the gross profit level associated with volume deleveraging and repackaging costs as we repurpose a certain portion of our existing foodservice inventory into retail SKUs. In light of these factors, we expect our gross margin to be sequentially lower in Q2 2020 compared to our strong margin performance in Q1 2020. As you have heard me mention previously, over the long term, we continue to believe that gross margin improvements will be delivered primarily through improved volume leverage, increases in throughput, greater internalization of our manufacturing footprint, materials and packaging input cost reductions, tolling fee efficiencies, and improved supply chain, logistics and distribution costs.

We remain committed to passing a portion of these cost savings on to the consumer as we pursue our goal to achieve price parity with animal protein in at least one of our product categories by 2024. In addition to leveraging our cost of goods sold, we were also able to achieve year-over-year operating cost leverage in Q1 2020. Operating expenses were 37% of net revenues in the first quarter of 2020 as compared to 40% in the first quarter of 2019. Net income was $1.8 million or $0.03 per common diluted share, as compared to a net loss of $6.6 million or $0.95 per common share in Q1 last year.

The strong improvement was primarily the result of the increase in net revenues and gross profit as well as operating expense leverage compared to the first quarter of 2020. Adjusted EBITDA was $12.7 million or 13.1% of net revenues in the first quarter of 2020 compared to an adjusted EBITDA loss of $2.1 million or negative 5.3% of net revenue in the first quarter of 2019. We note that the increased level of share-based compensation expense, which is an add-back to adjusted EBITDA, was largely due to appreciation in our stock price as well as substantially higher staffing levels versus the prior year period. Now looking at our capital structure.

The company’s cash and cash equivalents balance was $246.4 million. Total debt outstanding was $30.6 million as of March 28, 2020. Net cash used in operating activities was $15.9 million for the quarter ended March 28, 2020, compared to $13.3 million for the prior year period. Capital expenditures totaled $13.7 million for Q1 2020 compared to $3.8 million for the prior year period.

The increase in capital expenditures in Q1 2020 was primarily driven by growth capital, production equipment purchases related to our capacity expansion initiatives. On April 22, 2020, we announced that the company has entered into a new $150 million five-year revolving credit facility, replacing our previous secured credit arrangements. This new credit facility, which includes an accordion feature for up to an additional $200 million, increases our borrowing capacity, lowers our cost of capital and enables greater strategic flexibility for future global growth initiatives. We appreciate the strong support of our lenders in completing this transaction.

Finally, as we noted in today’s press release, and as Ethan alluded to earlier, given the unprecedented disruption and ongoing uncertainty related to the COVID-19 pandemic, including uncertainty regarding the magnitude and duration of the impact to the foodservice channel, in particular, we are suspending our 2020 outlook previously provided on February 27, 2020, until further notice. We believe this is the most prudent approach considering the extraordinary circumstances facing our global community, from consumers to businesses and governments alike. Over the long term, we remain committed to our strategic and financial objectives, anchored on innovation, including improving existing products and launching new ones, expanding brand awareness, growth of our distribution channels and investments in infrastructure and capacity to be able to serve Beyond Meat’s global market demand. With that, I’ll now turn the call back over to Ethan.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Thank you, Mark. In closing, we are very pleased with the results for the first quarter of 2020. Although we faced difficult challenges in the near-term operating environment as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, we remain optimistic about the long-term prospects for our business and believe that Beyond Meat continues to be well positioned to lead the global movement toward increased adoption of plant-based meats. I would now like to turn the call over to the operator for your questions.

Questions and Answers:

Operator

[Operator Instructions] Our first question comes from Ben Theurer with Barclays.

Ben Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Hey, good afternoon Ethan, Mark. So first of all, congrats on that strong result in the first quarter and hope you are all safe and sound.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Thank you.

Ben Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

So my question would be, you’ve alluded to it partially already. So you said March versus February was down around about 25% within foodservice. But clearly, March was only partially impacted. Could you share some insights on how April then trended versus March, and what you’re seeing more towards the end? Because we’ve gotten some commentary from protein companies that some of the foodservice have found ways in the QSR segment to kind of go back.

So the question is, have you seen a stabilization on a lower level in more recent days, weeks, versus the initial drop? And if you could share how much within your foodservice is actually QSR and how much is more like the other more of the — the real foodservice and delivery system, etc.? So that would be my main question.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Great. Thank you. So I’ll speak qualitatively to the first part of your question, just around the impact in April because we are not necessarily ready to share complete April numbers, of course. But overall, we did have a tremendous quarter, as noted with net revenues doubling year-over-year.

But we did see that the last two weeks of March become more problematic. I think if you look at the split, as you’ve mentioned, between large QSRs and the rest of operators in the foodservice segment, we’re about 33% of the strategic QSRs, and the rest are smaller, either regional or mom-and-pop organizations. So the larger QSRs were able to continue to generate business through drive-throughs and things of that nature, although diminished. And so we did see some sell-through occurring because of their ability to stay open, as well as to use services like DoorDash and Grubhub, etc., which we have partnered with and have been working well with.

And so I’ll get into this, I think, in other questions as well, but we really look at this challenge as how do we both reroute and repurpose? And in rerouting, we’re thinking about, how do we continue to get to the consumer even though the consumers’ normal patterns may be interrupted by this particular issue? And so we partnered with many of our organizations in the foodservice space to do that and in constant communication, whether it’s Subway or KFC, McDonald’s, Dunkin’, Starbucks, Hardee’s, Carl’s Jr., Del Taco. We’ve been in dialog with them around how can we serve them as a partner during this period of distress? And I think we found that patience is one of the biggest things we can contribute at the moment. They are trying to right the ship. I think they’re doing a good job of doing that. None of them have indicated that there’s going to be any change and decision to move forward with us or continue to expand with us. But they do need time now to reset their model, and we’re giving them that time.

We’ve also done some good things through them, so our Give A Million [Phonetic] campaign. If you look at Hardee’s, where we’ve teamed up with Erin Andrews and Ludacris to give out product or Carl’s Jr. with DeAndre Hopkins giving out product and Del Taco more recently with Jewel in Nevada giving out product to those in need.

So we have tried to be a partner throughout this period to each of our quick-serve restaurants here in the U.S. and in Canada, as they sought to move through this crisis.

Ben Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Okay. Perfect. Thanks. And then on the deal with Starbucks in China. So I remember you’ve initially — and you’ve mentioned that you still have the plans to get manufacturing into China. Now launching already with Starbucks in China, clearly a great opportunity, how much, considering the COVID-19 situation, is that early start actually with them in China a logistical headwind to not be present over there and to get product from your current production facilities over to China into the stores? Is there certain disruption at the beginning? And by when should we actually expect to start to see some of the products in the Starbuckses [Phonetic] in China?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Oh, it’s been great. And I think we’re really fortuitous in our timing there. We didn’t see much disruption at all based on the pandemic. There was maybe a slight delay, but they have executed flawlessly in getting this project up and running. So we’re getting some great results on social regarding the consumer acceptance of the product and looking forward to doing a lot more in Mainland China, as we’ve discussed. But Starbucks has been an exceptional partner in this regard.

Ben Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Okay. Perfect. I’ll leave it here and pass it on. Thank you. Congrats again.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from Rupesh Parikh with Oppenheimer.

Erica Eiler — Oppenheimer and Company Inc. — Analyst

Good afternoon. This is actually Erica Eiler on for Rupesh. Thanks for taking our question. So I guess, first, I was hoping maybe you could talk a little bit more about your ability to convert that foodservice supply into the grocery retail channel. So maybe a little bit more color on what you’re doing there.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Sure. We’d be happy to. And again, we said, as I mentioned in my comments, very early on, we set up a strategy, both offensive, defensive, to continue to grow throughout this period. And I think that’s been paying dividends recently.

And around the particular issue of shifting over from foodservice to retail demand, there are some very concrete things we did in terms of repurposing. We shifted foodservice lines over to retail production. We’ve been repacking foodservice into retail sale units and doing things like launching an Amazon Fresh nationwide. We’re also establishing our own direct-to-consumer system that will launch later this quarter. We’re working very hard with partners such as DoorDash and others, as I mentioned, to help get the product to the consumer, even if it’s still in the QSR system, and then going much more aggressively in club, so we can get consumers value packs and allow them to have more at home. We are also offering lower-cost value packs, not just in the club channel, but to retailers nationwide that are interested in taking advantage of lower-cost pricing and higher quantities. And so it’ll be interesting to see the uptake there given the spike in beef prices.

That will be rolling out in the next couple of weeks. And then more generally, as we shift more and more of the production, just very temporarily, right? I don’t think the foodservice situation is going to persist for that much longer. But temporarily, we are putting more and more resources into retail. We’re doing so at a pricing and cost structure that will allow us to get closer to the animal protein equivalent pricing, given the very significant surge in beef prices that’s just occurred.

Erica Eiler — Oppenheimer and Company Inc. — Analyst

Okay. Now, that’s helpful. And then just kind of shifting to kind of marketing and R&D, I mean, so you mentioned potentially delaying some of that marketing expenses as circumstances warrant. I mean can you maybe just talk a little bit about how we should think about marketing and R&D expenses going forward in light of the current environment? And then as we think about what’s going on in the QSR channel, how has kind of support and advertising there changed towards your product in light of the environment?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. So I think we take the marketing first. We really have sought to try to take care of our QSR partners. And so we’ve offered to do deals with them. We also are very focused on what we can communicate about our brand during this period. And so I think the Give A Million campaign is representative of that. We want to be part of the solution. And so instead of doing a lot of typical marketing, we sought to put resources into distributing free food to people in need and to frontline responders.

So I think that was something that we all felt strongly about at the company. I don’t think you’ll see us launch major campaigns right now. I don’t think this is the right time to do that. We’ll continue to try to be a solution. And one of the ways we can be a solution is to offer lower pricing. And so you’ll see us do more discounting this summer than normal just because of the opportunity to be relevant to the consumer as animal protein prices are spiking and supply is in short order. So it’s those type of commercial moves we’ll make versus more standard marketing. Innovation, we’ll always spend on innovation.

And so it doesn’t much matter what’s going on in the world. We’ll continue to do that. We’ve made adjustments across our budget in various areas to make sure that we’re still being very fiscally responsible. But we are, as I mentioned, an innovation engine, and that’s what we are at our core. And we have some long-term goals, and the short-term environment is not going to affect that.

Erica Eiler — Oppenheimer and Company Inc. — Analyst

Okay. Great. Thank you so much. I’ll pass it on.

Operator

Our next question comes from Steve Strycula with UBS.

Steve Strycula — UBS — Analyst

Hi, good afternoon and congratulations on a very strong margin quarter.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Thank you.

Steve Strycula — UBS — Analyst

So the first question would be just more backward-looking. How do we think about why the gross margin was so strong in the fiscal first quarter? I mean, your costs per pound were at record low levels, but what really drove like favorable unit economics as you think about deconstructing that? And then I’ve got a forward-looking question.

Mark J. Nelson — Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer

Sure. This is Mark. So we saw really good performance in the first quarter. Improvements year-over-year were balanced. A portion of that came from like variable cost inputs, direct materials and packaging. And the balance came from labor efficiencies and some overhead and variable efficiencies. So we are starting to see improvement in those variable cost items as well. A lot of our earlier gains had been really leveraging fixed costs, and we’ll still see some of that going forward.

But where we are starting to get some traction now was also in the material and labor variable cost inputs. And that will be an area we can continue to reduce costs.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

I think, just to add on to that, I mean, what I’m very proud of is the work that the operations team has done to get our pricing to be the lowest it’s ever been in terms — our cost structure to be the lowest it’s ever been, rather. That is an important milestone on our path to underpricing animal protein eventually. And so we’re going to continue to try to protect margin over the long run. We’ll make some adjustments in this quarter given the summer situation that help us grow our customer base and then consumer base, but we’re going to drive out this thing through cost reduction.

Steve Strycula — UBS — Analyst

Great. And Ethan, it sounds like you are being — you and organization being a very good partner to your end customers right now during this period. How we think about — you touched on the QSR channel, specifically what you guys are doing, but what are you doing on the retail angle and more like the independent part of the restaurant or foodservice business, if you will, to really drive value? You mentioned trying to narrow some of the price gaps. What are they asking for in terms of innovation or maybe slate that a little bit later in the year? Any type of new LTOs out there in the marketplace? That’d be very helpful. Thank you.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Sure. So I think on the LTO and new innovation, both on the retail side, I think, again, patience being the word of the moment here. These guys and gals are dealing with so much complexity even in the retail space, right, with just they’re closing their stores early now sometimes just to be able to restock. So the last thing you want to do is complicate their lives with a massive reset and try to bring in three or four different new items. But where you can be helpful is where they are in need.

And right now, they’re in need of basic protein. And so I think the move that we are making toward value packs and allowing the consumer to buy 10, 12 at a time, burgers, and bring them home, I think, is the right move. And so that’s helping retailers who have an issue with filling their selves with protein. It helps consumers because it provides very healthy and reasonably priced protein for them during this period.

On the QSR side, I think it’s very complicated right now to do LTOs. We have great fluid discussions with our major partners. And I think we are waiting for things to stabilize a little bit more before we begin to introduce any complexity on their menu in terms of pricing schemes and things like that. But you will see that from us as the year moves on.

Steve Strycula — UBS — Analyst

Great. Thank you.

Operator

Our next question comes from Ken Goldman with JPMorgan.

Ken Goldman — J.P. Morgan — Analyst

Hey, good afternoon everybody. Ethan, you mentioned that QSRs are not making any major decisions right now as far as your products. I did want to make sure, though, on Slide 11, just looking at the text there, it says McDonald’s Canada that, that test happened between January and April of 2020. And it’s the only customer on that slide with an end date. Am I reading too much into that line? Or did the test end last month? I just wanted to see if I’m missing something there.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. Yes. No, not at all. I mean the test was for that period, and it did conclude for no negative reason at all. I mean we feel very good about our relationship with McDonald’s and what’s going to be happening both there and potentially elsewhere. So by the nature of it being a test, it had a beginning and an end.

Ken Goldman — J.P. Morgan — Analyst

Can I follow up on that? Because typically, if a test did well, the retailer wouldn’t end it. They would expand it. So can you just help us understand a little bit why it stopped rather than going the other direction?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

I mean, I think it would require me to sort of open up the broader discussion. I can assure you, there’s no issue with McDonald’s. Let me put it that way. This is a way that it’s been planned and the way it’s being executed, and there’s been no change at all.

I can’t promise you that we will see a massive expansion tomorrow, but there’s been no change in information since we began this test and got good results in the beginning and got good results at the end.

Ken Goldman — J.P. Morgan — Analyst

Okay. I’ll leave it there. Thanks Ethan.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes.

Operator

Our next question comes from Alexia Howard with Bernstein.

Alexia Howard — Bernstein Research — Analyst

Good evening everyone.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Hey, how are you doing?

Alexia Howard — Bernstein Research — Analyst

Great. Can I ask about the pricing dynamics? You mentioned that pricing was maybe down in the quarter. Are you able to quantify that? And I guess looking out, you talked about the shifts to value packs and wanting to do sort of discount, more discounting. That’s kind of a different sense from what you have focused on in the past, which was to really whole-sizing. I’m just curious about whether we would expect to see net pricing per pound down more significantly as we roll forward. Thanks. And I have a quick follow-up.

Mark J. Nelson — Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer

For sure. And so, Alexia, in the quarter, when you look at volume, we actually sold 652,000 pounds. And if you calculate, our sales per pound was $5.83. Year over year, that’s very similar to a year ago. We were at about $5.88. So we haven’t seen net sales price erosion in that period. I think some of the discussion around what we saw in discounting was lighter in the first quarter, which allowed us to kind of maintain that net sale price per pound. And maybe looking forward, some of the things we talked about is introducing more value pack-oriented products and possibly increasing discounting.

We still feel confident in our ability to kind of match that with our cost reduction. But as we look to deliver some of these more value-priced items and deliver cost savings to the consumer, we’re going to look at continuing to drive that cost down.

Alexia Howard — Bernstein Research — Analyst

Right. And as a quick follow-up. You’ve given us an update pretty much each quarter about what the receipt purchase numbers look like. I can imagine that might have been disruptive, given everything that’s going on.

But do you have another number? And is it still in the mid-40s?

Mark J. Nelson — Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer

Yes. I believe that was — I think last year, we had some information that talked about repeat purchase activity…

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

It’s 45% — basically, 46%.

Mark J. Nelson — Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer

That’s correct. I don’t think we have an update to that.

Alexia Howard — Bernstein Research — Analyst

Okay. Thanks very much. I will pass it on.

Mark J. Nelson — Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer

Sure.

Operator

Our next question comes from Robert Moskow with Credit Suisse.

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Hi. Thank you. I might have missed it, but I think at the beginning of the year you said that you had some significant spending on consumer education programs about I guess the health and wellness of your product. And I want to know are those still happening? Or did you say that you’re going to kind of taper those off and put those into — put that spending into price instead? And then, I had a follow-up.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

So we did a lot of work to develop content which we’re holding, given the complexity of the global situation. And we will release it at the point in which we feel that the environment’s right. So I wouldn’t say it’s essentially a trade-off between doing that and putting directly into pricing.

We’ve held off on discounts in the past, and just feel now. We actually don’t feel any competitive pressures. You can tell by the 38% margin we enjoyed this quarter. But we do think it’s the right opportunity to take advantage of. Look at beef now, it’s $4.10 a pound wholesale assuming retail mark-ups take it up to about $6.80 or so.

We’re in pretty good shape to begin to make some inroads toward not necessarily price parity, but be in the same consideration set for the consumer. So you will see us spend and have more trade as a result.

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Okay. But Ethan, I thought what you needed to do was kind of defend the ingredients and your processes against some targeted campaigns that have been leveled against you. Is that what you’re referring to? But that’s kind of in your back pocket now? Is that right?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

100%. Yes, we have a ton of good development work going on in their content. And I just think people don’t want to hear that right now. The global components are elsewhere. Between us clashing our swords with the coming industry, it’s probably not the right idea.

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Right and then my follow-up is I saw a headline today saying that Impossible is launching in Kroger. You said that your price efforts here are really to show the value versus beef. But to what extent do you — are you and Impossible able to both grow together at these Kroger stores? Is that your expectation? And — or do you have to be price competitive against them also?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

My honest expectation is to win there, for sure, but I think there’s a place for both of us. And I think that, it’s two different consumers that are probably looking at those products. I think we — Impossible does a nice job. They are a great company, good people. I think it’s a different value proposition.

We’ve been very clear on non-GMO. And they have been obviously in another camp, not bad or good, truly. I mean — but I think that does appeal to a different consumer set. So it will be interesting to see how that unfolds, as they increase their distribution. I think we’re now in 90-plus-thousand points of distribution, 75 countries. So yes, I think we’ve got a pretty good head start and plan to keep it that way.

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Okay. Does that mean that your price cuts will go into place in those stores in which you’re head-to-head?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

It depends. I mean — so I want to give the right impression here. So I think one of the biggest focal point for me during this period is around these value packs and I want to make them available to any retailer who’ll take them.

We’ll do heavier discounting on some of our products as long as this disruption continues in the animal protein market. I haven’t really even thought about it relative to Impossible to be honest. I’m much more focused on the animal protein market.

I did want to clarify just on this — on the idea that a test somehow beginning and ending signals good or bad information. It’s really just not the case. If you look at KFC for example, that was a very successful test that had a beginning and an end. So I don’t want people to read into that. It just — it’s part of the — maybe ask them that on the next call. It’s part of their process of evaluating information. Again they don’t always go from test right to launch.

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Okay. Thank you.

Operator

Our next question comes from Brian Holland with D.A. Davidson.

Brian Holland — D.A. Davidson and Company — Analyst

Thanks. Good afternoon. I was curious if you could talk about — there’s been some commentary that consumers are migrating towards familiar products and brands in this environment, whether that’s just a pressured wallet or a migration towards comfort foods. On its face, that seems problematic for an emerging category, such as plant-based meat. Can you share any insight on what the consumer engagement is telling you about their willingness or non-plant-based adopters’ willingness to trial in this environment?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. I think we have snuck in just in the right amount of time into the national dialog and consciousness on this. Our aided awareness, brand awareness is about 52%. So I think when people think about plant-based meat, they’re thinking about Beyond, and so if they’re going to make any kind of trial during this period, we favor — or we come out pretty well on that because of the familiarity with our brand. So we’re not Campbell’s, right but we’re not so new that it seems foreign or novel in some regards.

Brian Holland — D.A. Davidson and Company — Analyst

Okay. Fair enough. And then I guess you talked about maybe pulling back on some of the marketing spend. It sounds like you’ll go to price discounting. I understand that. Certainly with the reduced foot traffic or impact to consumer mobility as it pertains to the foodservice channel, which I believe is a huge driver of awareness and trial for you guys, how else can you — I mean is it just pure just get the traffic that’s coming to retail, see the price discounting, see the value pack, see the availability? Do you feel comfortable that’s enough? Is there other — are there other alternatives you can look at here to sort of drive traffic and engagement right now if you’re going to move off of some conventional methods, sorry?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. No, great question. So this is an area that I love. And I really think that the way to market, particularly our products is around the authentic integration of the product into people’s lives and particularly people who have captivated the public’s imagination. So we use a lot of athletes or investors in our company. They are advocates for us. We use a lot of entertainers and they’re making changes in their own lives that are beneficial.

And one example that I actually love is Chris Paul, who’s a great friend of our brands. If you look at him in the 2020 All Star game, the guy’s 35 years old. He’s just about turned 35, catches a dunk right? And that he is maybe six foot two, right? And so after the game he says “I attribute this to shifting over to a plant-based diet; it has given me a lot of — more legs essentially right?” He don’t have to ice his knees so many times, etc. So you’re going to see us keep hammering home on that got milk message, right? That you consume our product you’re going to feel better. It’s going to do great things for you. And we’re going to have people that are out there in the public eye living proof of that. And so you’ll see more and more of us doing that. I think this giveaway campaign it wasn’t just Beyond Meat pulling up in a truck in the middle of the night and dropping off burgers. We partnered with some of the very famous people we work with, whether it’s Kyrie Irving, Snoop Dogg, etc. I mentioned many others. This is the way to market. It’s a genuine approach and it works because it’s true.

Brian Holland — D.A. Davidson and Company — Analyst

Got it. Appreciate the color. That’s all I have.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. Thank you.

Operator

The next question comes from Adam Samuelson with Goldman Sachs.

Adam Samuelson — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Yes, thank you. Good afternoon, everyone. I was hoping to first ask about the international business and I appreciate the new disclosure this quarter and just trying to think about more the sequential performance, the basis of the year-on-year is a little bit distorted. But sequentially it looked like the international business for both retail and foodservice was growing slower than the domestic U.S. business, which I found interesting because I would have thought there was a greater kind of distribution point gain potential internationally. So just any color there or issues around distribution, issues around logistics, seasonality. Just help me think about kind of the international business and the trajectory of that as we move into the second quarter.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. Okay. So I think the international business the reason that you’re seeing on a run rate basis somewhat of a decline just has to do with the really heavy amount of foodservice. It’s represented now about [Phonetic] 82% of the businesses is — was foodservice. It’s now about 76%. So you’re seeing just an out-weighted contribution from the foodservice decline globally.

We don’t think this is a — something that’s going to persist. We can’t predict the future of course, but you’re going to see going forward from us launches internationally in both retail and foodservice for the balance of the year that we’re pretty excited about. So overall, we look to foodservice — excuse me, we look to international as continuing to be a very, very strong pillar of our growth.

Adam Samuelson — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Okay. That’s helpful. And then I guess, the second question relates on the capacity side. And clearly coming into the year, you had some pretty meaningful aspirations on growth. You have new procurement — new raw material supply agreements on pea protein isolate. The demand environment is a little different today than it might have been 60 days ago. How do you feel about — just from a capacity perspective, are you now maybe a little further ahead on the capacity front than you need to be for the time being and willing to absorb that? Or just help us think about that balance as you try to balance growth and capacity?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

No, that’s great. I mean, my first plan of attack on this is this offensive strategy we put together and that really is around repurposing assets that may have been dedicated to foodservice over into retail, but keeping them nimble enough to be able to switch back as the situation improves.

So we haven’t yet encountered that issue. I mean, we — I’m not suggesting that we’re going to be completely unscathed by this. We’re not. We did take a hit on the foodservice side. But overall, if you look at all the different segments we entered, all the different opportunities for growth both from a foodservice perspective all the way to retail, lots of different types of retailers whether it’s club versus regular grocer and international with some parts of the world recovering more quickly than others. I don’t — one thing I’m not worried about is are we going to have excess capacity this year? We’ve built the appropriate amount of infrastructure. And then we, of course, use co-mans for some of our processes. So we can flex there. So I think we feel pretty good about where we are.

Adam Samuelson — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Okay. I appreciate the color. I’ll pass it on. Thank you.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Thank you.

Operator

Our next question comes from Rob Dickerson with Jefferies.

Rob Dickerson — Jefferies — Analyst

Great. Thank you so much. I guess just first question and maybe it’s too direct, not sure. It sounds like Q2 you said gross margin should be lower relative to Q1 given volume deleverage, repackaging cost. It sounds like there could also be some, I don’t know pack sizing or pricing effect too, not as much.

When you say volume deleverage, we obviously know there’s kind of — month of March, you referenced the trend in March off of Q1. Obviously, the mix on the U.S. side and the foodservice channel was higher. It would be more of an impact in Q2. So are you kind of saying — or let’s say, by saying that the margin in Q2 would be lower kind of given that volume deleverage, which would be coming from foodservice, not retail, that Q2 revenue in foodservice would actually decline year-over-year, right? I also ask, because we do talk about year-over-year all the time with Beyond. But for most emerging growth companies with revenue sub-$100 million, we really are watching this sequentially. And revenues technically did decline by $1 million right Q4 to Q1. So I’m trying to think about what’s that sequential impact potentially from Q1 to Q2 on the revenue side? Thanks.

Mark J. Nelson — Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer

Yes. So we — specifically, we’ll probably stay away from giving guidance, but as we go into the second quarter, we’re definitely going to have more of an impact on the foodservice channel, specifically versus the first quarter. First quarter was — through into March, we were relatively unimpacted. We started to see this impact in the month of March. And as we go into the second quarter, we’re going to see more of this impact. So maybe let you make your assumptions off of that, but we would anticipate the foodservice impact would be felt more wholly in the second quarter.

Rob Dickerson — Jefferies — Analyst

Okay. Fair enough. And then I guess more broadly for you Ethan, there have been a lot recently kind of around alternative protein space. So it’s highly fragmented still even though you are the leader in the refrigerated side. A lot of smaller players right potentially might be entering kind of a more challenging economic backdrop. It would seem like some of those smaller players might not be as well capitalized, right? You said strong balance sheet. You still — you have probably more scale than most in the industry right now.

So if you step back and look forward, let’s say, a year from now even if we kind of go through this tougher economic backdrop, how do you think that affects the industry? Like my first question was, hey, you could be more pressured in foodservice in the near term. But kind of longer term, it seems like if you have scale and the opportunity now that you actually could potentially be picking up more share going forward in a category that remains highly competitive.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. That’s exactly what we are pursuing. And we don’t look at this moment as a survive and advance moment. It’s really about how do we strengthen our position overall. And we think that relative to higher prices in the protein market today, we can make significant inroads into consumers and help them expand their choice of proteins. And so we look at that both on the animal protein market — more so in the animal protein market than on the plant-based meat side.

I think it is — we do have a very significant lead relative to other players in the plant-based meat segment group. And even the number one incumbent in this category, we grew six times their rate in the last 12-week period. So we continue to really advance more quickly than others. And that’s by design. We move very quickly.

The biggest thing for us right now around growth is, how do we provide solutions for the consumer as their other protein sources are rising in price and having supply disruption? That’s the biggest focus for us for growth. We think we’ve come out of this a much stronger company as a result, if we pay attention to what’s going on for the consumer.

Rob Dickerson — Jefferies — Analyst

Very helpful. Thank you so much.

Operator

Our next question comes from John Baumgartner with Wells Fargo.

John Baumgartner — Wells Fargo — Analyst

Good afternoon. Thanks for the question. Ethan on the marketing side, as you’ve launched in the U.S., you’re basically building this category from scratch. And as you go into Europe a market where you’ve got some plant-based competitors already. You’re pretty entrenched in Asia where it’s a bit of a different product. How does the market entry strategy differ? I mean, how are you approaching the communications different with consumers, with retailers, sampling promos and so on?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. So first of all, I wish I was over there now. I mean, it’d just be such an exciting time and I’ve been watching from afar the launch. We’ve had some really great advisers around us with a lot of experience in Asia. They’ve been helping us to understand that market and the consumer. And we will be announcing at some point a really terrific hire, we’ve made over there who’s helping to guide us; has a ton of experience in the market. So it’s entirely — there’s a lot of differences and we’ve got to be super sensitive to that.

And so I think, it’s also about picking the right partner. Starbucks is a good partner to go with. Initially, they’ve done a very good job of translating an American brand into the fabric of that country, and it’s well received by the Chinese consumer. But you have to be very sensitive even to the pallette right and making sure what we’re doing resonates from that perspective, from a nutritional perspective, from an ingredient perspective. So we’re all in, in that part of the world. We aren’t taking it lightly. We’re going to be investing a lot over there. And we expect to be part of the solution for what is a constrained protein environment over there as well.

I mean, if you — you don’t have to be a sort of systems analyst to look at what’s going on in the world and see that there are opportunities here for us to move more quickly whether it’s the coronavirus and the impact it’s had here on the U.S., meat industry or whether it’s the African swine flu, and the impact basically culling I think 60% of the Chinese hog population or more recent the avian flu occurrences in South Carolina and Ireland.

There’s an opportunity for the consumer to become aware of a different model of doing this. And we want to be as aggressive as we can to provide the consumer with that additional option. And so we need to do that in the parts of the world, where we can be most relevant. And certainly right now, China is front and center.

John Baumgartner — Wells Fargo — Analyst

Great. And then just a follow-up, I wanted to come back to the aggressive pricing and the value pack you mentioned at retail. And I guess for a product still very much in the trial phase, how do you think about getting a consumer to buy a 10-pack or a 12-pack for their first purchase? I mean, is there anything in the consumer work in terms of trial versus repeat, where you’re looking to kind of lean into here? Or is it more just a need to call the audible and just move that foodservice volume as quickly as possible. Club gives you the best chance to do that.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yeah. I think it’s — I mean, to me something really interesting happened for us. So if you look at our household penetration, so July of 2019 we were about 2%. We’re now at about 3.6%. But something interesting’s happening along the way. Our buyer rate which is the — this is the amount that each individual is buying, each household is buying is also increasing substantially, right? So we have a group of consumers that are not only consistently buying, but consistently buying more. And so to the extent, we can make some of this available to them, but also, if we can get close enough on the product that we’re competing against in the beef category itself, I think there’s enough momentum around our brand that we can get people to try it. They probably won’t first buy the 10. Maybe they’ll buy the two-pack, but we can offer more aggressive pricing on that as well this summer. So you’ll see both approaches from us.

John Baumgartner — Wells Fargo — Analyst

Great. Thanks for the thoughts.. Appreciate it.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes.

Operator

Our next question comes from Michael Lavery with Piper Sandler.

Michael Lavery — Piper Sandler — Analyst

Thank you. Good afternoon. Could you give a little bit of color on your retail expectations? You already had really strong momentum there running up around 200% even before the virus really had an impact. We’re seeing a similar pace hold up, but how do you think about what’s ahead? Should we expect an acceleration or some upside just especially as you ship capacity or see shortages of meat protein? Or is the volume lift likely offset by lower price? How do you think about just the next — the near-term runway there?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. I think it’s going to be a frustrating answer for me to give and probably to be received. We just don’t know, yet. I mean there are so many different moving pieces there. And does foodservice recover in a reasonable amount of time? Do consumers go for the value pack? Do they go for more aggressive pricing to the degree we think that they will? So there’s just so many variables.

What I can promise is that we’re — Beyond Meat’s fine throughout this process, throughout this issue thankfully because we have this split between foodservice and retail and we’ll continue to be fine. But we’re doing everything we can to try to be a solution during this period. And hopefully, the consumer will gravitate toward that. But we can’t make predictions now.

Michael Lavery — Piper Sandler — Analyst

Okay. Thanks. And just a follow-up on the margin side, you’ve obviously got really strong momentum in the first quarter, but — and recognizing there’s plenty of uncertainty still ahead, but any specific watchouts maybe we should have in mind? Is there a magnitude of an operating leverage hit that maybe we wouldn’t expect or an impact from some other costs? It sounds like, you don’t expect margins to turn negative but just would a reasonable thinking be some deceleration in margin momentum maybe a little less positive?

Mark J. Nelson — Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer

Yeah. I mean, once again trying to stay away from guidance. The second quarter, we do think is going to be sequentially down versus Q1. And that’s driven by probably overall volume and then also some of the volume leverage. We will be looking at increased levels of discounting. And so discounting was pretty low in the first quarter. And so that would be — also have an impact.

The move to kind of different kind of value pack sizes, those are probably — will phase in over time. So that’s not going to be something immediate and it’ll probably match our cost reduction initiatives. But really, just from the very near term, we think the second quarter would be sequentially kind of down from Q1, the very strong result we had here in Q1. But we probably couldn’t comment further beyond that.

Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from Jon Andersen with William Blair.

Jon Andersen — William Blair — Analyst

Hi, good afternoon everybody. Thanks for the question.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes.

Jon Andersen — William Blair — Analyst

Two quick ones. Putting the second quarter gross margin rate aside for a minute, I’m hoping you can talk about gross margin longer term. You’ve made so much progress on that line in the last year or so. How are you today thinking about margin rate, again, longer term in the context of your unit productivity that you expect and also though the reinvestment in price in order to try and achieve parity?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. So I think the number one answer in that regard is just around we’re going to continue to drive the cost structure down. And that’s where we’re going to see the most progress. And so you’re not going to see us sacrifice a ton of margin. I mean 38% is amazing. So we think we do have room to give back a little bit there and help ourselves be more competitive. But we don’t look at this and say how do we drive ourselves into a commodity position.

We want to very much take advantage of the efficiencies throughout our system. And I wish I could take you guys through. I mean, there’s so much that we can wring out of this system still. And we have the right people in the organization now to do it and they’re doing it. And I think, again I’m very proud of this milestone of the COGS we met this time around. But we’ll continue to drive that cost structure lower. And, yes, we will reinvest some of that margin into pricing to allow for more competitive outcomes, but I don’t think you’ll see us take a dramatic change from some of the margin that we’ve discussed in the past. I mean, this was a particularly good outcome. We’re not going to try to always meet that for sure. And as I mentioned this summer, we’re going to be very aggressive on pricing. So there’s another piece of data. But, overall I’m pretty comfortable with the dialog we’ve had in the past on margin and don’t expect that to change.

Jon Andersen — William Blair — Analyst

Great. That’s helpful. On e-commerce, you talked a little bit about it in your prepared comments. How — there’s been a shift to online. It’s been accelerated as a result of COVID-19 pandemic. How are you positioned online? How do you plan to broaden your reach there and kind of take advantage of the momentum that you have to make sure you’re really available anywhere the consumer wants to interact and kind of transact with your brand?

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Yes. There’s a lot of energy in this building around that particularly because our COO came over from a long career over at Amazon. And so first Amazon Fresh, right? I mean so we’re doing a lot there with that launch. And then we are looking at our own system but who knows on that right? We’ll see. But overall, we’re trying to change with the consumer. And are we going to become Omaha Steaks? I’m not sure. But we’ll — we’re going to again try to reroute every way that we can to make sure that we’re getting our product to consumers who want it. And online is obviously one big part of that. But I think you’ll see the most — if I had to guess, the most traction right now out of — near term out of Amazon Fresh.

Jon Andersen — William Blair — Analyst

Okay. Thanks so much.

Operator

And I’m not showing any further questions at this time. I’d like to turn the call back to management.

Ethan Brown — Founder, President and Chief Executive Officer, Board Member

Okay. Thank you guys very much for the terrific questions and for following the brand over the last quarter. As I mentioned, we do feel very strongly about — this an opportunity in time for us to be aggressive in offering the consumer expanded protein options. And so look forward to seeing how we wrap the second quarter here and getting back on the phone discussing results.

Thank you very much. Most importantly do stay healthy and safe. Thanks.

Operator

[Operator Closing Remarks]