Loblaw Companies Limited (L) Q2 2022 Earnings Call Transcript

Loblaw Companies Limited  (TSE : L) Q2 2022 earnings call dated Jul. 27, 2022

Corporate Participants:

Roy MacDonald — Vice President of Investor Relations

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Analysts:

Mark Petrie — CIBC Capital Markets — Analyst

Irene Nattel — RBC Capital Markets — Analyst

Michael Van Aelst — TD Securities — Analyst

Patricia Baker — Scotiabank — Analyst

Vishal Shreedhar — National Bank — Analyst

Chris Li — Desjardins — Analyst

Kenric Tyghe — ATB Capital Markets — Analyst

Peter Sklar — BMO Capital Markets — Analyst

Presentation:

Operator

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. And welcome to the Loblaw Companies Limited Second Quarter 2022 Results Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] This call is being recorded today, Wednesday, July 27, 2022.

I would now like to turn the conference over to Roy MacDonald. Please go ahead, sir.

Roy MacDonald — Vice President of Investor Relations

Thank you very much, Michelle. Good morning, everybody. Welcome to the Loblaw Companies Limited second quarter 2022 results conference call. As usual, I’m joined here this morning by Galen Weston, our Chairman and President; and by Richard Dufresne, our Chief Financial Officer.

And before we begin the call, I want to remind you that today’s discussion will include forward-looking statements which may include but are not limited to, statements with respect to Loblaw’s anticipated future results and the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. These statements are based on assumptions and reflect management’s current expectations. As such, are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results or events to differ materially from our expectations. As such, are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results or events to differ materially from our expectations. These risks and uncertainties are discussed in the company’s materials filed with the Canadian securities regulator. So any forward-looking statements speak only as of the date they are made and the company disclaims any intention or obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, future events or otherwise, other than what’s required by law. Also certain non-GAAP financial measures may be discussed or referred to today, so please refer to our annual report and other materials filed with the Canadian sec securities regulator for a reconciliation of each of these measures to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measure.

And with that, I will turn the call over to Richard.

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Thank you, Roy. And good morning, everyone. I’m pleased to report that our performance in the second quarter, continued to build on our positive momentum. Our business mix as is well positioned for the current environment and our focus on retail excellence is delivering steady and consistent operational and financial performance. During the quarter we delivered solid top and bottom line performance. We continue to focus on delivering value to consumers and carefully managing our expenses all part of retail excellence.

On a consolidated basis revenue grew by 2.9%, adjusted EBITDA increased by 9.3%. And adjusted earnings per share grew by 25.2% to a $1.69 a share. Our GAAP earnings reflect a charge of $111 million associated with a recent Tax Court ruling relating to the deductibility of certain loyalty related expenses over the last 13 years. We are planning to appeal the ruling.

In drug retail, absolute sales increased 7%. Same-store sales were strong up 5.6% lapping an increase of 9.6% last year. Front store same-store sales grew by 5.2%. We continue to see an acceleration in sales growth in our higher margin categories led by OTC and cosmetics. Sales in beauty and cosmetics are essentially back to pre-pandemic levels. Pharmacy, same-store sales grew 6.1%. Although we are seeing an acceleration in both acute and chronic prescription volumes, we have not yet caught up to normal levels. Once again, growth in our pharmacy services business was strong with all major categories showing double-digit growth. Pharmacy services now include our Lifemark business which closed on May 10, contributing $40 million in sales.

In Food retail, absolute sales increased 1.2% and same-store sales grew 0.9%. Performance in our discount banners continue to strengthen, reflecting an ongoing shift in favor of discount. As part of our store network optimization initiative, we now have five stores that have been converted from market to discount and have downsized to one market store. We are pleased to report that all such projects are performing ahead of plans on sales and therefore, are contributing to earnings. Our market banners remain strong and continue to perform well. And great in-store offer enhanced by optimized promotion using our data have led to positive traffic trends and solid sales.

Online sales in the quarter decreased by 17.5%, however, our online business continued to operate at penetration levels well above pre-COVID rates. We are seeing consistent, stable operational performance and pickup and growth in delivery. We are delighted with our launch of PC Express Rapid Delivery through a collaboration with DoorDash. The service will launch in Q3 and will not represent a headwind to earnings.

Retail gross margin in Q2 was 31.4%, up 50 basis points compared to last year, driven by our drug retail business. Higher margin front store categories, particularly cosmetics, grew substantially as customers returned to offices and social settings. Margins also benefited from growth in pharmacy services, with COVID-related services remaining strong. Gross margin performance in Food retail was stable. Our unique data lets our merchants set more strategic pricing and promotion levels. With grocery inflation as it is, this is an important balancing act.

As our results today and for the last quarter, show our businesses are doing well and remain profitable. They all sure show that this improved performance has resulted from the return of customers to our higher-margin beauty and drug businesses and the fact that increased pandemic costs are slowly going away.

Retail SG&A as a percentage of sales was 19.9%, an improvement of 30 basis points compared to last year. We lapped higher COVID costs in the prior year and continued to benefit from sales leverage, food to drug sales mix and operating efficiencies. This was partially offset by higher labor costs across the network. Adjusted retail EBITDA increased by $129 million or 9.8% in the quarter, yielding a margin of 11.4%.

We were pleased with PC Financial’s performance in the quarter. Revenue was up $25 million, driven by higher interchange and interest income, with a broad-based increase in customer spending. Contribution to adjusted EBITDA from the bank was flat as we lapped last year’s gain related to reversal and expected credit losses reserves and saw higher points costs due to higher PC points redemption. On a consolidated basis, adjusted EBITDA margin was 11.7% in the quarter, up 70 basis points compared to last year. In Q2, we repurchased $607 million worth of common shares, representing 5.4 million shares. This brings year-to-date purchases to $755 million.

Looking ahead, macro factors continue to make forecasting challenging. We are seeing signs that inflation has or will soon peak. As such, we expect inflation to moderate in the second half of the year as we begin to lap higher levels from last year. Commodity prices are coming off their highs, some freight costs are coming down and supply chain issues are normalizing other than fuel costs which remain high but down from their peaks of last March. Finally, central banks are taking aggressive actions to tame inflation.

Today, we announced an increase in our full year outlook. Based on our year-to-date operating and financial performance and momentum exiting the second quarter, we now expect full year adjusted earnings per share growth in the mid- to high teens. We have just cycled the first quarter of our 2021 strategic reset, delivering growth of 25% in EPS this quarter on top of 88% in the same quarter last year is beginning to demonstrate that our plan is working. Our focus on retail excellence is delivering strong and consistent financial results. While the environment remains volatile, Loblaw is well positioned for what is expected going forward.

I will now turn the call over to Galen.

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Thank you, Richard and good morning. I’m pleased with our performance in the quarter during this period of global financial uncertainty, prolonged pandemic, caution and global inflation. As Richard noted, our retail revenue performance was strong and consistent with earnings growth linked principally to our drugstore business.

Shoppers Drug Mart had an excellent quarter, generating high-margin sales in beauty and cough and cold, while expanding pharmacy services created for Canadian patients. These services and the pharmacists who deliver them are becoming an increasingly critical part of our country’s primary care delivery network by providing expanded access to basic medical assistance at low cost. As a matter of interest, as part of this evolution of our health care delivery strategy, last month, we opened Canada’s first walk-in clinic staffed exclusively by pharmacists. And in the neighborhood with a critical physician shortage, this has been met with an enthusiastic local response.

Our food business also performed well in the quarter with good sales and stable gross margins. Our conventional market stores are competing well, consistently outperforming peers. This is in part driven by a strong relative price position and outstanding performance of several enhanced merchandising programs. The consumer shift to discount also continues and is substantially benefiting our hard discount formats where we see new customers coming through the doors every day.

As you know inflation remains a significant external force shaping business performance. However, as Richard mentioned, we are seeing some signs of stabilization. Commodity costs are substantially off their highs and transport and freight rates are improving. Having said that, supplier costs are still high, putting sustained pressure on retail prices. We continue to work hard to reduce their effect for our customers. This includes operating two of the lowest priced formats in the country with No Frills and Maxi, investing in our famous low-priced private label brand, no name, the second largest consumer brand in the country and seeing historic growth.

Not to mention, the over $1 billion of savings our customers will earn this year through our PC Optimum program. In fact, we just completed a piece of work which showed that customers who engage in the full benefits of the PC Optimum program are consistently saving as much as 10% on their grocery bill.

Touching on one more retail trend, digital sales continue their retreat of pandemic highs and we expect to return to e-commerce growth once we fully cycle the last of that COVID demand and continue to improve and expand our offer. Delivery is growing as part of our channel mix. And in Q2, we announced our partnership with DoorDash to serve as our primary last-mile delivery solution. This relationship includes an exclusive presence on their marketplace and the introduction of a 30-minute rapid delivery service. We remain bullish on what’s to come.

Loblaw’s purpose is to help Canadians live life well. As the country’s largest private employer, we endeavor to do that every day through innovative products at great prices, convenient access to high-quality health care services, the country’s best credit card and high-quality apparel. But it is often the smaller activities of our teams that can make the biggest difference and I wanted to close my remarks with a particular example that stood out.

At the start of the invasion of the Ukraine, a small group of colleagues stepped forward, interested in how we could contribute to the humanitarian response. As a company that marshals nearly $100 million a year to give back to local communities, this group of colleagues started with the question, how can we better support those who are building a new life in Canada? They observed that the diversity of our business put us in a uniquely compelling position to do so. In the months since our team has partnered with government, NGOs and our customers, contributing and raising millions in support to provide the building blocks for families who have lost life’s most basic ingredients, including jobs, food, wellness, clothing and financial products, a near perfect manifestation of our purpose.

At Loblaw, we continue to execute our strategy in the midst of a challenging period. We remain confident in our short-term outlook and our longer-term opportunities.

Thank you. I’ll now open the call for questions.

Roy MacDonald — Vice President of Investor Relations

Thank you, Galen. Michelle, could I ask you to remind the participants, the protocol for asking a question?

Questions and Answers:

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen we will now begin the question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] Your first question comes from Mark Petrie of CIBC.

Mark Petrie — CIBC Capital Markets — Analyst

Yes, good morning. I wanted to ask about the retail gross margin. And I know generally, you’ve been talking about sort of stable trading or stable gross margin but mix is clearly a pretty favorable tailwind. And you also have media as another tailwind as it becomes more material in the coming years. So can you give us a sense of the magnitude of the mix impact and sort of your implied medium-term outlook across channels? And is there an overall number that kind of makes sense to shoot for just understanding that mix piece? I mean 32% would seem like a good target. Just sort of wondering how we should sort of think about a longer-term kind of margin outlook.

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Hi, good morning Mark. No, we don’t have a specific target as to where we want the gross margin to go. We’re just trying to manage our business the best way we can. But we do feel good about our gross margin position now and then going forward.

Mark Petrie — CIBC Capital Markets — Analyst

Okay. And perhaps you could just talk a little bit about some of the bigger picture opportunities for that margin? I mean as a — media is one that’s come up and I can’t imagine you’re going to give specific disclosure on that. But directionally, anything would be helpful. And then also, the puts and takes in the Shoppers business because, clearly, the recovery in the front store is helpful but the pharmacy services is presumably going to be somewhat of a headwind in the second half of the year. Just sort of curious how you’re thinking about the margin opportunity at Shoppers?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Yes. The key driver of gross margin going forward that will continue to be retail excellence and running our retail business as best we can. Talking about Shoppers specifically, like, obviously, mix has helped. We’re going to see growth taper a bit because if you look at services, they were starting to grow at this time last year and accelerated in Q3 and Q4. So we’re not going to see the same trend this year but we do feel very good about our services business for the overall of the year. And so, therefore, like we should not see significant increase in margin as we’ve seen so far, it’s going to start to slow down.

Mark Petrie — CIBC Capital Markets — Analyst

Okay. And if I could just add one more. It was another good quarter in terms of opex management, particularly in the cost of inflation. But given the nature of your labor contracts and the longer duration of those contracts, how do you think about the outlook for SG&A over the medium term? I mean should we be expecting above average inflation to be stickier in opex and potentially last longer than in other parts of your operations?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Yes. I think the organization has done a good job at managing SG&A so far. But it’s important to point out that last year, at this time, we were still in lockdown. So a big improvement in SG&A this quarter has to do with just lapping those costs. So we’re going to come into a more normal environment going forward but we do feel good about our ability to manage SG&A going forward.

Mark Petrie — CIBC Capital Markets — Analyst

Okay, thanks for the comment. I’ll pass it along. All the best.

Operator

Thank you. The next question comes from Irene Nattel, RBC Capital Markets, RBC Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

Irene Nattel — RBC Capital Markets — Analyst

Thanks. And good morning everyone. I’d like to spend just a few minutes talking about the same-store sales number because, with inflation at 9.6%, I think, we were all expecting a slightly stronger same-store sales number. But of course, the offset is channel shifts and mix shift. So can you please talk about what you’re seeing, how you view same-store sales, what consumer behavior is and how that all comes together?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

So good question, Irene. I think it’s important to reflect on what’s been happening more last year than this year. Like, first of all, we’re very pleased with our sales trajectory as it’s going right now. But if we go back last year, at this time, in Q2, we were in full lockdown, okay? And unit counts, when we were in lockdown, benefited.

And when we get into July of next year, like that’s when essentially all restrictions got lifted. So people essentially started to go out significantly. And we saw marked dropped in our unit count starting last summer which has continued throughout this year. So as we move into Q3, we’re going to be cycling these unit counts. And you’re going to see a marked shift in same-store performance which does not mean anything other than what happened last year because we don’t see a change in our sales trajectory going forward.

Does that help?

Irene Nattel — RBC Capital Markets — Analyst

Yes, that helps. So just to make sure that I’m clear, it’s not so much that your revenue run rate is changing Q3. It’s just that on a year-over-year basis, the growth looks better. Is that the way to think about it?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

That’s exactly the way to look at it because like in Q2, like we were — essentially, it was the first quarter that we essentially had no lockdown restrictions at all, okay? And we were comparing it to a quarter last year where we were all stuck at home. So that’s why you see like a same-store sales figure that is lower. As we get to Q3, you’re going to start to see a sales performance that reflects like people starting to go out. So you’re going to see a marked increase in comp performance starting Q3 and we’re in Q3 now and we’re seeing it. So that’s what I think, the Street needs to appreciate.

Irene Nattel — RBC Capital Markets — Analyst

That’s helpful. Richard, can you talk — or Galen, can you talk a little bit about what you’re seeing in terms of consumer response to inflation, the magnitude of the channel shift, how much trade down are we seeing just in terms of branded private label but also just among categories and anything that you can provide would be very helpful?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, Irene, I know you asked this question every quarter and I think I give largely the same answer. The trends today are essentially the same as they were in Q1 which is that shift to discount continues at pace. Price sensitivity is growing. Promotional intensity is a little bit higher. As I mentioned in my remarks, we’re seeing control brand growth across the board, both at President’s Choice and at no name, continuing to accelerate.

And then we are seeing — what I’d call kind of volatility in how people are trading protein depending on the price in any given period. So there’s really not much more to say than that. Those are the trends. And it might be a little bit more meaningful today than it was in Q1. But the trends are largely — are directionally all identical. And then maybe I’d add just one more incremental bit of context. We do, through our financial services business, so we have a pretty good indication of the health of our consumer and payment rates remain at historic high levels which suggests that, at least with a large subset of our customers, they’re still in reasonably good financial shape. And so that is, call it a buffering effect on inflation.

Irene Nattel — RBC Capital Markets — Analyst

That’s helpful, thank you. And then just one final one, sticking with consumer behavior, obviously, market — Walmart shook up the market earlier this week around their commentary. Anything you can share with us on what you’re seeing in the right-hand side of the store, whether it’s Joe or just the general merchandise more broadly defined?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. I mean a couple of highlights. Joe Fresh business was positive in the quarter, although we are starting to see a little bit of softening in that as we look forward. And the right-hand side outside of apparel was notably down and it was definitely — had a drag on our overall comp sales results. But the key in these circumstances is inventory. And so the question is, how do you feel about inventory? And do you have aggressive markdowns that you need to put through to clear that inventory? And the answer is, we feel good about inventory and we don’t see any meaningful margin risk associated with clearing what’s left.

Irene Nattel — RBC Capital Markets — Analyst

That’s great. Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. The next question comes from Michael Van Aelst at TD Securities. Please go ahead.

Michael Van Aelst — TD Securities — Analyst

All right, great. Thank you. Just going back to Irene’s questions around trade down and shift to discount and private label penetration increasing, how do those factors impact your same-store sales? Is it — like, when you calculate your inflation and comment on your inflation, is it on just a unit-by-unit basis? Or does that inflation take into consideration the trade down in proteins and the shift to discount and things like that?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Inflation captures everything, Michael, like I think it’s tough to answer your question but like it’s prevalent throughout our business. We’re seeing a bit less in private label than in other categories. And on the commodity stuff, it fluctuates like it has always been.

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. So simply put, we use an internal proxy. So we look at CPI and then we look at our version of that basket to calculate our internal inflation. So in that respect, it wouldn’t take into account the mix shift. But we also look at a series of what I’d call kind of supporting metrics to triangulate the number which are much more inclusive and would capture a portion of the mix shift for sure. Does that help answer the question?

Michael Van Aelst — TD Securities — Analyst

Well, so I understand and so it’s clear. So the inflation is capping the actual unit price changes but your trade down in proteins and private label, that’s more being captured, I guess, within the de facto tonnage number that everybody calculates?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. I mean think about looking at the average article price across the entire enterprise and what’s happening in terms of its change. It’s not specifically weighted for volume, if you understand what we’re saying?

Michael Van Aelst — TD Securities — Analyst

Yes. Okay. All right. That’s helpful. And can you guys give us an indication of how much inflation is impacting the front store pharmacy?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, it’s about the same. I mean there’s not as much inflation in health and beauty. But certainly, we see the same inflationary pressures and all the consumable goods in the front store of Shoppers Drug Mart. So that’s a positive contributor for sure.

Michael Van Aelst — TD Securities — Analyst

If front store is 5.2% of total same-store sales growth, are you getting tonnage growth or unit count growth?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Well, we are because we’re seeing substantial growth in key categories that are all driven by units. So think about flu, cold medications, we’re seeing major unit growth in cosmetics, substantial unit growth and all things that were essentially declining categories last year.

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Yes. COVID brought so much volatility in front store and pharmacy that it’s tough to look at it like we look at it at food but like these categories are coming back. And right now, cough and cold, it’s like we’re in the middle of winter, right now. So this is sort of an unusual phenomenon.

Michael Van Aelst — TD Securities — Analyst

Okay, great. And just finally, on the network optimization, I think you had 17 stores originally identified for either banner changes or downsizing. And you mentioned five at the start of the quarter. I can’t remember what you might have had in Q1, if at all. So what’s left to do this year? And based on your — what your — I guess, what you’ve been seeing of the results, where do you see this number being in the future years? Or even do you have any plans to expand that shorter term?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Yes, Mike. So it’s probably like a little bit less than 10% for the rest of the year. So we’re going at pace. Obviously, it takes time to get all these projects going but now they’re well on their way. So over the next few months, we’re going to be reopening a few every month. So that’s progressing nicely.

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

And then — yes. And then if you think about network optimization as a general strategic principle, just keep in mind, it’s about adding new stores where there’s high population growth and high potential for incremental sales. It’s about converting banners to more optimal formats and it’s about downsizing stores and productively making use of the downsized space.

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Yes. So since Galen is expanding, I’m just going to add one more thing to it, like new stores takes a little bit more time to get going. So you’re going to see more new stores than typical more next year. Same for downsizing, takes more work to get to agree to a downsizing like where are you going to do the downsizing, who’s going to come in and they get extra space? But those are also getting momentum. So this year, you’re seeing way more conversions because those are easier to effect. And so that’s what the bulk of what you’re going to see until the end of this year.

Michael Van Aelst — TD Securities — Analyst

All right, thank you.

Operator

The next question comes from Patricia Baker of Scotiabank. Please go ahead.

Patricia Baker — Scotiabank — Analyst

Yeah, good morning everyone. I just want to come back to a discussion on the retail gross margin and, obviously, Shoppers mix had a very nice impact in the quarter. And you indicated that the food retail margin was stable or flat year-over-year. And that’s been a trend that we’ve been seeing over the last several quarters which is quite nice because we’ve had years and you talking about wanting to stabilize that margin. So when we think about and you think about the food gross margin, do you think that the full gross margin is where you want it to be and that we should think about that, that it will just remain in a stable range?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Patricia, we feel very good about our gross margin in general in both our Food and Drug segment. I don’t want to comment more than that at this point.

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

And maybe I’ll add just to — so we did a lot of work over the last 18 months to — we’ve talked about this to remove wasted investment in our kind of margin structure. So that’s been very helpful as a driver of growth in food margin. And then, going forward, it’s about optimization. And we talk a lot about data and we are still in, call it the mid-earning innings of that journey. And so there is opportunity to continue to get more efficient. But it will be at the margin more so than funding changes.

Patricia Baker — Scotiabank — Analyst

Okay. That makes perfect sense. And then just in your discussion of the network optimization, are you in a position, Richard, to give us a sense of what square footage growth you’d be looking for next year when you’re opening new stores?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Not yet. I will have a good sense of that like probably around Q4, Patricia. But our plans are sort of being put together as we speak.

Patricia Baker — Scotiabank — Analyst

Okay, fair enough. And then just the last, Galen, I was — I am intrigued by the walk-in clinic stacked entirely by pharmacists. I think that’s a really interesting idea. So I assume at this point, that’s a pilot project but you probably see opportunities depending on how it performs to roll out more of these at some point in time? And then can you just talk a little bit about what sort of services those pharmacists are providing in that location?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. So starting with the principle of increasing, call it, basic primary care delivery pharmacists. The biggest potential for that is within our pharmacies. And the biggest potential for that is within Shoppers Drug Mart pharmacies. What we’re doing with — what we’re doing in this town with this dedicated clinic is we are taking over excess space inside a superstore and we are testing an expanded service experience. So we have four consultation rooms. We have four pharmacists and we are seeing patients on a very, very frequent basis. And so the way to think about the future is, as the provinces get more confident in expanding the scope of practice for pharmacists, we see an opportunity to have selective, dedicated locations that can provide a health-clinic-like service delivered by pharmacists. In terms of the types of services that they are delivering, it’s the same things that you have heard us talk about before. So its minor ailment, prescribing, cold sore medications, strep throat, UTIs and travel vaccinations all the sort of the basic levels of care that pharmacists are trained to administer and to deliver.

And the single regulatory barrier to that happening on a provincial level is working with the government to expand the scope of practice for those pharmacists. And as I think we’ve also mentioned, we’re expecting to see 12 new expanded practices coming to Ontario before the end of the year. And so there’s, we believe, some runway ahead to help improve, substantially, access to care for Canadians by leveraging what pharmacists are already trained to do.

Patricia Baker — Scotiabank — Analyst

Okay, thank you very much. Sounds really interesting.

Operator

Thank you. Your next question comes from Vishal Shreedhar from National Bank. Please go ahead.

Vishal Shreedhar — National Bank — Analyst

I was hoping you could give us some perspective on the food market share between restaurants and grocery stores. Do you anticipate the restaurant industry to take more share back? Or is that largely stabilized, similar to the cosmetic trends that you called out earlier in the quarter?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Well, maybe I’ll comment directionally as opposed to with specifics because these things are all moving with multiple forces sort of putting pressure on them. So without question, when the world opened up, you saw a flood of customers going into restaurants that has a natural dampening effect on retail grocery sales. But of course, as prices go up, prices are going up higher in restaurants — higher and faster in restaurants than they are in grocery stores. And so that has the opposite effect which is it starts to push people back into the supermarkets where they are looking for a value-added equivalent to a restaurant meal.

And one of those merchandising programs that Richard and I touched on in relation to our market division has been the sustained and accelerating success of our entire value-added meal program. We’ve done a lot of work in that space and are really, really pleased with the results. And one of the things we think is driving that is that you can get a fresh prepared salmon dinner that can serve four for $15 and you’ll never get that at a restaurant. And that is a big part of where we see opportunity for customers as food prices continue to go up.

Vishal Shreedhar — National Bank — Analyst

Okay. Just changing gears here, as you look at your in-stock positions and labor position and labor staffing in stores, are they at adequate levels now?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Well, they should always be better. But yes, we’ve improved substantially over the last three or four months. And we are always focused on in-stock positions but it’s no longer what we would consider a critical issue for the enterprise which is a good sign. It’s not back to pre-COVID levels and that’s a function of the continued disruption in manufacturing that’s out there but the teams are managing pretty well. When it comes to labor availability that is a material pressure. We’ve talked about it before. It tends to be in pockets rather than sort of system wide. Certainly, this summer, it’s been a challenge in our distribution centers in certain parts of the country and we’re working hard to backstop that. But at the moment we don’t see labor availability as a material disruptor to our ability to do business.

Vishal Shreedhar — National Bank — Analyst

Okay. And you commented on the conventional banners. Is it fair to say that conventional banner performance was negative? And how is that trending most recently? And how does management feel its performance of conventional banners is versus peers? I know you indicated some color on that in your disclosure?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. Well, there’s no question that volume is shifting out of the market segment, the conventional segment and into the discount segment that is impacting our business. So we look at our performance relative to peers, as you asked and we’re very comfortable, in fact, very pleased with the way that our market division is performing in that context. And again, it’s hard to comment on what — whether we’re positive or negative because, as Richard mentioned, how you cycle through last year’s volatility has a very meaningful impact on what your sales growth actually looks like. So it’s been both negative and positive; that’s the matter [Phonetic]. But as Richard said, the actual sales dollar rate has been pretty consistent.

Vishal Shreedhar — National Bank — Analyst

Okay. And with respect to how the customers have gone back to discounts similar to pre-pandemic levels, do you anticipate that trend is going to be sticky? Or the customers that, that segment has won? Or do you anticipate there could be a return back to elevated levels of conventional?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

I think it moves — remember, we’ve got extraordinary forces out there. We’ve got unprecedented levels of inflation. We have all kinds of different things going on in terms of the economic confidence and the money that people have in their pockets. But the macro trend, if you look back over the last 10 years, is that the discount segment has been growing largely faster than the market division. And I would say that trend is likely to continue if you were to fast forward over the next 10 years.

Vishal Shreedhar — National Bank — Analyst

Thank you for the color.

Operator

Thank you. The next question comes from Chris Li, Desjardins. Please go ahead.

Chris Li — Desjardins — Analyst

Hi, good morning. Galen, just maybe a follow-up to the last question. When you mentioned that conventional is outperforming your peers. Just curious what data are you basing that on? Is that the Nielsen data? And then secondly, can you call some of the initiatives that are helping you drive that outperformance? Is that mostly in your strong own brand portfolio and your loyalty program? Thank you.

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, I think you’ve answered the question. So we use Nielsen to measure our share and our relative share performance and we — and the merchandising programs include what I mentioned which is the value-added food program. It’s very, very effective activation of PC Optimum in our market stores. And certainly, we would say and I would say, given my own exposure to our stores, our operating conditions today are more consistent than they have been in the past which is contributing very positively. And then control brand. I mean, I don’t know the last time you went into one of our stores. We have a big no name program running in the supermarkets, the conventional business today and it’s been a terrific success for us.

Chris Li — Desjardins — Analyst

Yes. No, that’s helpful. And another question maybe on Shoppers. You mentioned earlier that the sales of the high-margin front store categories are now pretty back — much back to pre-pandemic level. Is that also true for the gross margin level for the Shoppers business overall? Has it also returned to pre-pandemic level? Or is this still below?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Yes. Gross margin on front store is back to normal. Pharmacy, there, we still have some work to do.

Chris Li — Desjardins — Analyst

Okay. And my last question is maybe a longer-term question. As we look out to next year, there’s maybe a potential for some deflation. When I look back at the last deflationary period in late 2016 and first half of 2017, Loblaw, actually, I think, managed to achieve very solid earnings growth supported by tonnage growth, the effective promotions and good expense control. I know you don’t have a crystal ball but just wondering, do you expect this to be the case again this time, especially with some of the retail excellence initiatives that they’re in progress right now?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Well, for us, like we’re always thinking about building solid plans for the years coming and that’s what we’re working on right now. And the team is all aligned so that we can deliver on our financial framework for 2023.

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. I think, Chris, yes, we’re pretty — we have — historically, we’ve had a good track record of performance in deflationary or low-inflation periods. I think that may be partly because we have such a big discount business and it’s very good at managing SG&A and leveraging volume. But in terms of predicting what inflation is going to look like next year that is still hard for us to get a grip up. But if it were deflationary, we’re not concerned about our ability to deliver in that environment.

Chris Li — Desjardins — Analyst

Okay. Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Your next question comes from Kenric Tyghe, ATB Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

Kenric Tyghe — ATB Capital Markets — Analyst

Thanks, Galen. Good morning. Galen, can you spend a minute on the beauty business. You called out the strength in that — in the recovery and beauty and cosmetics. Can you just sort of speak to the supply chain and how supply is actually responding given the pace of that recovery and that it’s not a recovery unique to Loblaw but the broader market. Is there any risk there with respect to the beauty business that you end up sitting in a position in the back half of this year where suppliers are simply unable to keep up with the pace of that recovery? Or are you comfortable with sort of supply conversations in beauty and cosmetics given how important they are to the margin profile and what a lift they provided in the first half?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. Today, we’re not concerned about the — look, the availability of the product is not perfect and because the beauty vendors are struggling with a lot of the same general supply chain issues that the rest of the market is. But we don’t see a shortage, if that’s the question you’re asking, materializing here. This is a return — well, it’s — for the most part, it’s a return to normal as opposed to a major demand surge. It just fell so far during the COVID period. The one place that just anecdotally we’ve been mystified with this, there’s tremendous strength in fragrances and we are kind of wondering what people are doing with all of those perfumes. But that’s the only place where it might be running a little ahead of that return to normal.

Kenric Tyghe — ATB Capital Markets — Analyst

So, actually — got it. So short version grocers and retailers are much better at managing a return to normal than airlines apparently. I won’t quote as is [Phonetic] off-guard is what I’m hearing — saw coming?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Look, we believe so.

Kenric Tyghe — ATB Capital Markets — Analyst

Fair enough. And then just one more quick one for me. Richard, I heard you’re calling out that the higher PC point’s redemption in quarter. How material was that in terms of the underlying or sort of fundamental shift in behavior and how do you think about the — not just the evolution of that through the back half but managing elevated points redemptions through the back half?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Yes. The elevated redemption starts with us issuing more points. So like our merchandising team throughout the organization are like — are beginning to see more traction and more benefits of using loyalty, so they’re using it more. So we saw a marked increase in the issuance. And because of the current environment with high inflation, it’s also affecting redemption. So this is something that we’re really happy about and we hope to see more of it going forward. And we expect to be issuing even more points in 2023 than we have planned for 2022.

Kenric Tyghe — ATB Capital Markets — Analyst

Okay, thank you. I will leave it there.

Operator

Thank you. The next question comes from Peter Sklar of BMO Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

Peter Sklar — BMO Capital Markets — Analyst

Good morning. Back on the consumer. So your basket is down despite the basket inflating 9.5%. Richard, in your comments, you seem to attribute that to the pantry’s loading that was going on last year when everyone was shut in. But I’m just wondering if you could also comment on the health of the consumer that’s being squeezed by high food and fuel prices and just general overall inflation and has less, really less in their wallet. I mean would you attribute some of that to the weakness of the consumer, if you could just elaborate there, I’d appreciate it?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

The thing we’re clearly seeing is new customers, so visits and number of transactions are up. And if you go to our stores, like you’ll talk to store managers, they’re seeing clients they’ve not seen in their stores for a long time. So I think that’s what’s happening. That’s the more prevalent factor that’s driving those metrics.

Peter Sklar — BMO Capital Markets — Analyst

So like if your basket is down, though it’s inflating 9.5%, your item count must be down dramatically. Isn’t that true?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Item count is —

Peter Sklar — BMO Capital Markets — Analyst

I’m not so sure how that relates to new customers.

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Yes. Item count has been down since July of last year, okay? And — but there’s a significant shift in item count and as quarter three begins because we’re cycling what was like a lockdown last year.

Peter Sklar — BMO Capital Markets — Analyst

Right. Okay.

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

So, we’re not seeing significant change in trends on sales and tonnage like going into sort of Q3 and in Q2. And — but it’s like to what you’re comparing it with that sort of creates all of this noise.

Peter Sklar — BMO Capital Markets — Analyst

Yes. So I think what you’re saying you’ve now, in Q3, you would have lapped the pantry loading. So it’s going to be more of a cleaner quarter.

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

Yes. And then in the — towards the end of that quarter, we’re going to start to cycle the beginning of inflation. So you’re going to start to see that effect. Now we’re starting to see the cycling of the unit count. And a month or two from now, we’re going to be cycling the beginning of inflation. So those have been all reflected in our comp and we’re going to have to explain what’s happening specifically to understand what’s going on. But the major point is that we’re pleased with the trajectory of our sales at this point.

Peter Sklar — BMO Capital Markets — Analyst

Okay. Got it. Just last question on e-commerce that was down 17.5%. Assuming that you captured most of that decline and converted them to in-store shoppers at Loblaw banners, I assume that’s a positive because, I mean, you have less people running around picking and delivering to — delivering to people’s cars in the parking lots. Would that have been — would that have had a noticeable positive impact on margins or other operating parameters? Or is it just something small at the margin?

Richard Dufresne — Chief Financial Officer

It’s small at the margin but your first assertion is true. We actually tracked the customers who will move from online to in-store and like essentially a large majority of them are back in store. But you’re right, like it’s not a significant impact on our margin.

Peter Sklar — BMO Capital Markets — Analyst

Okay, great. Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. [Operator Instructions] Our next question comes from Irene Nattel of RBC Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

Irene Nattel — RBC Capital Markets — Analyst

Thanks. At the risk of like really beating this horse, coming back to the whole issue of item count and item pricing. I just want to be very clear. So if we take peanut butter, if I trade down from, let’s say craft to no name. Let’s just say it’s a 10% lower unit cost. Now that unit cost maybe higher year-on-year but overall it’s a headwind to your same-store sales. Is it not?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. But we look at — yes.

Irene Nattel — RBC Capital Markets — Analyst

Okay. Okay. So, do you think that — I can get, obviously, what we’re all trying to do is triangulate the 9.6% and the 0.9% to really understand. And I think we get that the comp is tougher in Q2. I think what everyone is just trying to understand is whether you’re losing share or not? It’s on the bottom line.

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. And I think Richard did a very nice job trying to bring it back to the sort of the fundamental premise which is there’s a ton of comp noise and that noise is impacting the read of the results. And we see it even more acutely because the opposite is the case right now in the way that the business is performing. And it’s not a function in any meaningful change in the trend. It’s just a function of noise on the comparables. And so we’ll all be happier when we get through all of this cycling and we’ll be able to see the numbers cleanly. But the underlying performance from our perspective, we are very satisfied with. And that’s the key message. And we expect that outlook to remain through the balance of the year.

Irene Nattel — RBC Capital Markets — Analyst

That’s great. And then, just one final subject — one final question on that subject. Again, coming back to the Walmart commentary. Based on your numbers, do you think you guys are losing market share to Walmart in Canada?

Galen Weston — Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer

Well, on an overall market share basis, we are very confident about the trajectory that we’re on. Certainly, Walmart, we’re watching carefully. They’ve had some very strong quarters in terms of sales performance in their discount business. And when we look at our discount business performance today, Maxi and No Frills are particular highlights in terms of their performance. And so if I put it this way, we’re less concerned about that gap today than we were, say, two months ago.

Irene Nattel — RBC Capital Markets — Analyst

That’s great. Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. There are no further questions at this time. Please continue.

Roy MacDonald — Vice President of Investor Relations

Great. Thanks, Michelle and thank you, everybody, for your time this morning. I’m — we’ll be around waiting for your calls this afternoon. And you can mark your calendars for November 15th when we’ll be releasing our Q3 results. Thanks, again, and have a great day.

Operator

[Operator Closing Remarks]