Paychex, Inc. (PAYX) Q1 2023 Earnings Call Transcript

Paychex, Inc.  (NASDAQ: PAYX) Q1 2023 earnings call dated Sep. 28, 2022

Corporate Participants:

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Analysts:

Bryan Bergin — Cowen & Company — Analyst

Jason Kupferberg — Bank of America Merrill Lynch — Analyst

Andrew Nicholas — William Blair — Analyst

Ramsey El-Assal — Barclays — Analyst

Eugene Simuni — MoffettNathanson LLC — Analyst

Bryan Keane — Deutsche Bank AG — Analyst

Kevin McVeigh — Credit Suisse Group AG — Analyst

Jordan Boretz — Jefferies, LLC — Analyst

James Faucette — Morgan Stanley & Co., LLC — Analyst

Tien-Tsin Huang — J.P. Morgan Securities, LLC — Analyst

Mark Marcon — Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. — Analyst

Jay Meade — Northcoast Research — Analyst

Scott Wurtzel — Wolfe Research, LLC — Analyst

Presentation:

Operator

Good day everyone, and welcome to the Paychex First Quarter FY ’23 Earnings Conference call. [Operator Instructions]

It is now my pleasure to turn today’s program over to Martin Mucci, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Paychex. Please go ahead.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Thank you Gretchen, and thank you for joining us for our discussion of the Paychex First Quarter Fiscal ’23 Earnings Release. Joining me today are John Gibson, our President and Chief Operating Officer; and Efrain Rivera, our Chief Financial Officer. I do want to start out by saying that all of us who are thinking of everyone in the path of Hurricane Ian that is approaching Florida at this time, certainly, our employees, our clients and everyone else in those areas, we hope are safe.

This morning before the market opened, we released our financial results for the first quarter ended August 31st, 2022. You can access our earnings release on our Investor Relations website, our Form 10-Q will be filed with the SEC within the next few days and this teleconference is of course being broadcast over the Internet and will be archived and available for approximately 90 days.

We’ll start today’s call with an update on business highlights for the first quarter, Efrain will then review our financial results and outlook for fiscal 2023 and then we’ll open it up for your questions. I will start out by acknowledging that this will be my last earnings call, as in my role as CEO of Paychex. On August 24th, we announced I’m retiring as CEO effective October 14th, that’s after our 2022 — fiscal 2022 Annual Meeting of Stockholders. However, I will remain in my role as Chairman of the Board.

John Gibson on the call today, our current President and Chief Operating Officer will assume the role of President and CEO. John has been a member of the executive leadership team since 2013, and has been instrumental in the success of Paychex during his tenure. We have executed on a long-term succession plan and I’m confident that John is the right person to lead Paychex into its next phase of growth, really many best days ahead of us.

I want to thank all of you also, you directly for your interest in coverage of Paychex, some of you for more than two decades and for your good questions and feedback over my 12 years as Chief Executive Officer. I also want to publicly thank Efrain, everyone knows he is one of the best CFOs in the business and we’ve done over 40 quarterly calls together and more than any — more than a CFO, Efrain has really been a leader on our executive team and who provides not only great counsel, but is known for his intelligence, his integrity and also a music trivia, you can try that out on some time.

Fiscal 2023 is off to a great start with a double-digit growth in both revenue and earnings compared to the same quarter last year. We have a record level of first quarter sales, with strong trends continuing in the midmarket, retirement and HR outsourcing in particular. We have had continued success in the selling of our suite of innovative products from HCM technology to HR solutions, that help businesses become more efficient and address complex HR issues in a challenging time for many businesses.

We continue to regularly monitor our key leading indicators for signs of changes to the macroeconomic trends and while we’ve seen some moderation in key issues, we have not yet seen any significant changes. As an example, the latest Paychex IHS Small Business Employment Watch showed that workers of U.S. small businesses continue to benefit from higher wages, new jobs continue to grow, but at a more moderated pace and job growth at U.S. small businesses remains resilient, even in the face of a tight labor market and inflation pressures. Employment levels at our existing clients have continued to increase, as they’re finding more people to fill those positions, consistent with these findings of our HR — of our Small Business Index.

I will now turn the call over to John and he will provide you with some highlights surrounding our technology and product suite and results. John?

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Okay. Thank you Marty, and good morning everyone. It’s a pleasure to be with you. Based upon our recently released Pulse of HR Survey, it’s obvious that businesses of all sizes continue to be challenged with attracting and retaining talent, improving their operational efficiency and working to increase their financial flexibility. Our continued investments in innovative HR technology, combined with our unmatched HR expertise, truly and uniquely positions us to help small businesses and mid-sized businesses navigate a very dynamic and challenging environment.

Earlier this month, we attended the Annual HR Technology Conference in Las Vegas, where once again Paychex demonstrated the latest of our innovations. We showcased significant enhancements to the Paychex Flex recruiting an applicant tracking experience, which is designed to digitally deliver candidates to clients faster and allow them to leverage mobile technology to recruit, screen and then onboard candidates in a unified and simple to use experience. Already our digital on-boarding experience was utilized by over 1.7 million new hires in the last year alone.

We also introduced our latest innovation Paychex Voice Assist and really this is a natural extension of the expansive and ever-growing and utilized self service capabilities that we have at Paychex, and coupled with our award-winning Paychex pre-check offering, which allows employees to further participate in the Payroll process by reviewing their gross to net payroll calculations prior to payroll processing.

Paychex Voice Assist now enables HR and Payroll administrators and small business owners to manage their payroll and HR task while on the go through any Google Assistant capable device. This provides a hands-free experience that includes voice recognition and verification security. I’m proud that Paychex is the first HCM solutions provider to offer voice activated capabilities such as these.

Our technology offerings continue to garner national recognition. Paychex is proud to be recognized for the 6th, I repeat the 6th consecutive year by NelsonHall, a global analyst and research firm and they’ve positioned us as a leader in its 2022 [Phonetic] NEAT Report for service providers. Paychex Flex was recognized for its comprehensive technology as one of the most advanced HR platforms that brings the power of benchmarking, data analytics, as well as digital service enablement to drive operational efficiency and improve the employee experience.

I also want to mention that we have once again for the 12th consecutive year been recognized as the nation’s largest 401k Recordkeeper by total number of plans by PLANSPONSOR Magazine. We were also recognized by them as an industry leader in the number of new plans that we added in 2021. It’s obvious that our retirement business continues to be an area of strength for us, as many business owners and their employees are focused on financial wellness as a key benefit an issue.

In addition, our pooled employer plan offering continues to gain traction in the marketplace with approximately 4,000 new plans on-boarded during the first quarter alone. We continue to see strong demand for our employee retention tax credit service. This helps clients maximize their eligible tax credits and thus provide more financial flexibility. To-date we have helped over 45,000 clients secure over $8.6 billion in and combined ERTC and paid leave tax credits. We continue to have the opportunity to educate more of our existing clients on the benefit of this service, as well as leverage the service to attract new clients.

We have started off the fiscal year ’23 strong and while there is uncertainty in the macro environment, our solutions and business model have in the past and continue today to prove the resilience. We help our clients to succeed under any macroeconomic conditions. We continue to focus our product roadmap on the needs of our clients and anticipate releasing further enhancements this fiscal year, designed to continue to provide them a positive digital user experience and help them utilize HR technology to simplify their processes.

Now before I turn the call over to Efrain, I’d like to take a moment to say thank you. And yes Marty, you’re going to continue to hear this over and over again over the next couple of weeks. But I want to say thank you to Marty for his tireless dedication and strong leadership of the company over the years. And for me personally, for his mentorship and his friendship for the nearly decade that he and I had been working together.

Under Marty’s tenure as CEO, Paychex has more than doubled its revenue and transformed into a leading HCM technology solutions company. Today Paychex is a tech company and it’s a tech company because of Marty’s vision and his leadership. Marty, it’s been a pleasure to work alongside you, the leadership team, and the nearly 17,000 now employees of Paychex and I look forward to continuing our relationship in our new roles.

As I’ve said many times and too many people, we’re the same great company, it’s the same great leadership team, it’s the same great employees, we’re just each playing a little different roles as we move forward. I know that our collective focus on our purpose, which is to help small and mid-sized businesses succeed will continue to drive us in the future as it has in the past.

I’ll now turn the call over to Efrain to discuss our first quarter financials.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Okay, thanks John, and good morning. I’d like to remind everyone that today’s commentary contains forward-looking statements that refer to future events and therefore involve risks, refer to the customary disclosures.

Let me start by providing key points for the quarter and finish with a review of fiscal 2023 outlook. As Marty and John already mentioned, Q1 was strong, our financial results for the first quarter included service revenue and total revenue that increased 11% to $1.2 billion. Management Solutions revenue increased 12% to $906 million, driven by higher client employment levels and revenue per client; revenue per client was positively impacted by additional product penetration, HR ancillary services largely or ERTC product and price realization. We continue to see strong attachment of our HR Solutions, retirement and time and attendance solutions.

I’ll note that the revenue from our ERTC service benefited our first quarter revenue by about 1% to 2%. While we had anticipated ERTC revenue would continue in fiscal 2023, strong execution both in sales and service allowed us to realize some of the revenue a bit earlier in the year. While ERTC was a tailwind to growth for the first quarter, it’s benefit will decline as the year progresses. For the full year, the impact will be marginal to growth.

PEO and Insurance Solutions revenue increased 8% to $283 million, driven by growth in average worksite employees and PEO health insurance revenue. The rate of growth was tempered by a lower rate of health insurance enrollment in both the PEO and the insurance agency, together with continued softness in workers’ compensation rates. So that really is a little bit more focused at — the insurance agency has more of an impact on the revenue there.

Interest on funds held for clients increased 24% for the quarter to $18 million, primarily due to higher average interest rates along with growth in investment balances. Total expenses increased 11% to $711 million, expense growth was largely attributable to higher headcount, wage rates, and general cost to support growth in our business. In addition, PEO direct cost increased due to higher medical plan enrollments compared to the same period last year.

Op income increased 12% to $496 million, with an operating margin of 41.1%, an expansion of 20 basis points over the prior year, a bit above where we anticipated it being in the first quarter. Our effective tax rate for the quarter was 22.9% compared to 24.9% in the prior year period. Both periods reflect discrete tax benefits related to employee stock-based comp payments. However, the prior year also reflected an increase in state taxes. Net income and diluted earnings per share both increased 14% to $379 million and $1.05 per share, respectively. Adjusted net income increased 15% and adjusted diluted earnings per share increased 16% for the quarter to $372 million and $1.03 per share, respectively.

Our financial position remains strong with cash, restricted cash and total corporate investments was at $1.3 billion and our borrowings were at approximately $800 million as of the end of the quarter, cash flow from operations was $364 million during the first quarter, a small decrease from the prior, driven by fluctuations in working capital, partially offset by higher net income. And we paid out quarterly dividends at $0.79 per share for a total of $285 million in the first quarter. Our 12 month rolling return on equity was a stellar 46%.

Now, I’ll turn to our guidance for the current fiscal year ending May 31, 2023. Our current outlook incorporates our first quarter results in our view of the evolving macroeconomic landscape. One thing I want to emphasize, as I walk through the guidance, we don’t provide quarter-to-quarter guidance, what we try to do is, give you a sense of where we anticipate the quarters will fall. So I’d ask that you keep that in mind. The majority of our guidance remains unchanged from that provided in June with the exception of an increase in our expected growth for adjusted earnings per share.

Let me provide some color in certain areas as follows. Management Solutions revenue is expected to grow in the range of 5% to 7%, but now we anticipate it to be towards the upper end of the range. PEO and insurance solutions is still expected to grow in the range of 8% to 10%, but we now anticipate it to be towards the lower end of the range. Interest on funds held for clients is expected to be in the range of $85 million to $95 million, but is now again anticipated to be towards the upper end of the range. Total revenue is expected to grow in the range of 7% to 8%, but again based on what I just said, is anticipated to be towards the upper end of that range. And adjusted diluted earnings per share is now expected to grow in the range of 11% to 12% increase from the previous guidance of 9% to 10%. I just want everyone to remember I’m talking about adjusted diluted earnings per share.

So, turning to the second quarter, our current thoughts are that we anticipate revenue growth will be approximately 7% and we expect operating margins to be approximately 38%. Of course, all of this is subject to current assumptions, which could change if there are significant changes to the macro environment, and we’ll update you again on the second quarter call and I refer you to our investor slides on our website for more information.

I’d also like to take a moment to thank you. But let’s say thank you to Marty for his years of service to the company. It’s been an incredible pleasure working alongside you and I wish you the best of luck in your future endeavors. I can say that for all of the shareholders on the call, there was never a moment, never a conversation where putting the interest of shareholders didn’t come first, and so I know that that will continue under John’s leadership. So the other thing I’d like to say is that, the company that we’re reporting on today simply would not be where it is today without Marty’s efforts.

Hey, one other thing that I want to add to, for the investors on the call, we filed the supplemental proxy statement this week relating to our “say on pay proposal”, we’d ask that investors who want a position in Paychex take a look, read that closely. I’m always available, the management team is always available for any calls that you’d like to schedule to discuss that.

So with that, let me turn it back over to Marty.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Thanks, John and Efrain. Thank you very much for the comments and for your updates. And also of course, we wouldn’t be here where we are today, if the company without our over 16,000 employees who have worked so tirelessly for our clients and for our shareholders.

We’ll now open it up for your questions and comments. Gretchen, please open the — open it up, please.

Questions and Answers:

Operator

[Operator Instructions] We’ll take our first question from Bryan Bergin from Cowen. Bryan, your line is open.

Bryan Bergin — Cowen & Company — Analyst

Hi, good morning, thank you. Marty, John, congrats.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Thanks, Bryan.

Bryan Bergin — Cowen & Company — Analyst

I wanted to start here, if we can talk about really the — making a little bit more around the moderation comment you mentioned on some of the KPIs and any changed view on macro assumptions in that fiscal ’23 guide, particularly on client employee levels and retention?

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Yes, I don’t think so. I’ll let John comment too. But I think what we’re seeing in the moderation is, like on retention, I think that we’re kind of heading back toward — we’re still above from a revenue retention standpoint, we’re still above pre-pandemic levels, on a client retention, we’re kind of normalizing back to a pre-pandemic. We kind of expected that, there was a lot of new business growth, new startup business growth over the last couple of years during the pandemic. And so you’re seeing a few more of those go out of business and you’re seeing a few more bankruptcies that way.

And the other thing that we’re seeing in the small business index as well, wages are going up, they’re starting to slow down and moderate. So while job growth is still growing and moderating some for small businesses, wage growth is starting to moderate slightly, so that’s maybe a good sign that some of the actions being taken by the Fed are working and maybe that will continue to improve.

But other than that, sales continue to be very strong. So when you look at that side of it, we’re at record levels of sales. We had a great first quarter in sales and clients are adding employees. So, the moderation is probably more on the retention side normalizing and — but the number of employees being added in the sales are still very strong.

John, anything you want to add?

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yes, no, I would say, I don’t think there’s anything we’re seeing at this point that would see as a sign of a recession. And as Marty pointed out, there is — there was moderation that we expected going into this year on retention because of the business charge. But when I look at it, employment levels continue to be — increase, we see that in our checks, we see that in worksite employees per customer, the labor market continues to be tight, our business watch certainly showed that information.

I would also your point to, our revenue retention is remaining at the record levels we’ve seen before. So again, we continue to see the fact that retention and the use of our products. When I look at the underlying pieces, clients are taking high value services from us, those things are creating more stickiness for those customers that are our price value losses continue to remain significantly below even the pre-pandemic level. So again, anything, any moderation that we’re seeing, I view as more of a normal — normalization of what we kind of saw anomaly going on during the pandemic.

Bryan Bergin — Cowen & Company — Analyst

Okay, thank you. And then just, Efrain, for the 2Q rough targets that you provided here. Can you just talk a little bit more there on the dynamics. First on growth, as we think about moving from 1Q to 2Q. And then just on margin, you had out performance on margin in 1Q, are there added investments that come back into the model over the course of the year, particularly in 2Q?

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Yes, a little bit. So let me just talk to that, because obviously the growth rate in Q2 is a little bit different. This year was always a little odd, because the two highest growth quarters were the first and the last and the middle for different reasons, a little bit idiosyncratic to the processing, for a planned process ended up a little bit lower. In Q2, I’d call out three things, Bryan, that are important. We don’t anticipate that the level of ERTC, I called it out in the quarter, will — the amount of growth contributed by ERTC will continue in the second quarter. Having said that, I don’t know, because I didn’t think that was going to happen in the first quarter, so we could be a little bit more, but I’m being a little bit cautious about what we think we will get. So you won’t quite get — you won’t get that level of uptick in growth in Q2. And these comments are about Q2, by the way we’ll talk about the back half of the year when we get a little bit closer to back half of the year.

The second part is that, we had to — to the points, although there has been discussion about moderation, what was really interesting in the first quarter is that, we had higher growth in what we’d call check volume and pays per control [Indecipherable] than we anticipated in our plan. First quarter was actually fairly robust, out of an abundance of caution, reading the same info you are reading, we think we’re still going to get some benefit in Q2, but it won’t be as pronounced as it was in the first quarter. So that will cause a little bit of a step down and then with respect to PEO, we called out some trends that are persisting with around — and PEO insurance around after attachment that we think will continue into second quarter, that’s going to drive growth, a bit small — or a bit lower than we were. We’re really consistent in some ways a little bit above what I said when we were in the fourth quarter call. That’s really what’s driving it, it really is more of a Q2 from an investment side.

The challenge for this year was we entered the year — we were — in the first half of the year, last year, we were really at much lower employment levels than we are currently. And so as we have a little bit of a step down in revenue in Q2 or as you have a step down in revenue in Q2, you still have relatively higher expense level, but normalize as we get into the back half of the year. And then we’re making investments in marketing, product development, the normal things that you would make in a quarter and that combines to kind of create a little bit of a lumpy Q2. So that — those are the key factors in terms of underlying dynamics, no change and it’s pretty much in line with what we anticipated.

Bryan Bergin — Cowen & Company — Analyst

Okay, thank you very much.

Operator

Next question comes from Jason Kupferberg from Bank of America. Jason, your line is open.

Jason Kupferberg — Bank of America Merrill Lynch — Analyst

Sorry, I apologize, I was on mute. Well, first of all, congrats to Marty and John. I did want to start with a question for Efrain, just on the EPS guidance raise, Efrain, is this just because you now think revenue and margin will both be at the higher end of your full year expectations? I know everything else is kind of unchanged, so just wanted to make sure we have the pieces there for EPS?

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Yes, I think for the full year we’ll be a little bit ahead, I’d say. I think it’s more driven, Jason, by more mix. So there is some revenue component to it and there is a mix component to it that’s driving the EPS number.

Jason Kupferberg — Bank of America Merrill Lynch — Analyst

Okay, got it. Just the float income guidance for fiscal ’23, I know it’s unchanged, you’re talking about being at the higher end. I guess maybe just given the magnitude and the speed of the Fed rate hikes, can you walk through some of the pieces there? Some people I think might have thought that that number would be moving a bit higher, but obviously there is portfolio duration and other variables to consider? Yes, that’ll be helpful.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Well, Jason, thank you. That — so look, I’m a little bit cautious and I think — and I think we could be accused of some conservatism there. But you’re absolutely right. And just to get one level deeper and get a little bit more into the question that you’re raising. I think that the issue for us is, at what point do you — do you see the Fed raising and then you locked long based on duration. I don’t have the great answer to that, I will say we’re meeting basically every other week to decide what our outlook is on that. That could impact that number. I’m looking not only at ’23 and ’24, you were here long enough to know when we rode that cycle up and then had a bumpy cycle on the way down.

And so I want to avoid that, even at the expense of maybe a little bit of upside this year. So, we’re trying to figure all that out and then where — you’re reading the same things actually better than I do. One second, it looks like short-term interests are going to go to X and the next second someone says, hey, I’m a little bit concerned about that “recession”. So balancing all of that with the appropriate level of conservatism so that we can hit what we said, we feel good about the forecast at this stage based on what we know, is a little bit trickier — we’re certainly at the high end of that range. And we’ll update next quarter.

Jason Kupferberg — Bank of America Merrill Lynch — Analyst

Okay. Just one last quick one, just in that — picking up on that team of potential conservatism. I mean, just looking at Management Solutions, obviously you’re sticking with 5% to 7% for the year, you started to 12%, you had some of the ERTC benefit, but it just seems like a lot of decel kind of baked in. So, maybe you want to talk through that a little bit, I know you’re talking about higher end, but still?

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Yes, I’d say this. I think — and we’ll talk more as we get to kind of mid-year. I think one of the things that ends up happening with ERTC in the back half of the year, it becomes a headwind to growth, because it doesn’t recur in the same way that revenues do, so we baked that in, that’s one — we’re against tough comps in the back half of the year, so that’s another issue. And then employment is really the other part that we’re wondering about. Right now, say, we’re not assuming that there is a lot of employing adds in the back half of the year. Could we see some — something that’s different than that? I don’t know, both ways. At this point I can’t call it close enough. So, I’m sticking with where we thought we were going to be at the beginning of the year and then we’ll update as we go through the year.

Jason Kupferberg — Bank of America Merrill Lynch — Analyst

Fair enough. Thank you, Efrain.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Okay, thank you.

Operator

Our next question comes from Andrew Nicholas from William Blair.

Andrew Nicholas — William Blair — Analyst

Hi, good morning. Thanks for taking my question. Wanted to start on the PEO and insurances or Insurance Services segment. Obviously, growth came in on the bottom end of the full-year range. You’re now guiding to kind of lower end of the range for the full year. I know you mentioned some weakness in the insurance business this quarter, is there anything else to call out within that business that surprised you, whether it was to the upside or the downside? It sounds like existing client hiring activities are still quite strong, sales are good. So just want to make sure I understand all the dynamics there as well.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Let me frame it and then I’ll let John talk to it. He’s obviously — know first in what’s going on. But in terms of the dynamics of the business, in terms of the plan and forecast and our guidance, we started out the year a little bit lower on the insurance side than we had anticipated. That’s primarily an issue around — and we called it out on enrollments. We think that trend will persist into the second quarter and then it will start to improve as we get into the back half of the year. So we have a little bit lower first half than originally anticipated and in the back half as we expected. So that’s what’s really kind of moving the PEO numbers down in terms of our outlook.

Look, you know, Andrew, better than the most. Differences in attachment can change revenues really, really quickly. And so, we’ll see where we end up on that front as we go through the year. It’s driving it — it’s driving our results, largely it doesn’t have a significant impact on margin. Again, as you know, because those are relatively low margin revenues, but out of a sense of, I’d say, at a sense of where we ended up in the first quarter and where we’re anticipating second quarter to be, we’re good.

Now I’ll let John talk about the fundamentals of the business, because I think they actually are pretty strong.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yes, look, I feel, particularly on the PEO side, we’ll talk about that first. Like we’re well positioned coming out of the first quarter, remember, we’re just now really entering the key selling season. We’re also in open enrollment season within our PEOs and those are two critical periods of time when I look at where we are going into this. Our client retention is extremely strong, really we had set some pretty aggressive targets and we’re actually beating those targets in the PO in the first quarter to the value proposition is resonating, so retention was very strong, sales were strong for the first quarter. I look at where we are from a sales head count, we actually accelerated. If you remember in the fourth quarter, we made — said we made some investments, in the first quarter some of that was actually adding because we saw the demand there, are 10 years great. We have the best sales retention in many of our divisions in the PEOs, our a tenure of our team going into the selling season is really strong.

We just completed our renewals with our health insurance carriers. I feel good about where we are on those. I think we got a good part of that. To Efrain’s point, kind of the attachment of insurance and then once we attach insurance to a client, how many employees are signing up for that, again, in particular, it’s may be an affordability issue we’re maybe seeing. So some of the things we’ve done is we’ve actually expanded low cost plans in this next enrollment. We’ve expanded our enrollment consultants who will go out and engage clients. So we’re working against what we’ve kind of seen some trends in the first quarter, but obviously some of the drag in revenue, as Efrain said is, we have a little lower than we historically have seen relative to attachment of insurance in the PEO and a little lower participation than we’ve typically seen as well. And again, we’ve taken steps in terms of both plan design and in our sales execution, be able to move forward.

The agency — insurance agency, some of the things we saw relative to attachment and participation in our H&B area, similar to PEO, common theme there that we saw in the first quarter. And then as we’ve talked about, I think repeatedly, the market — just the market is continually soften in P&C and continues to be a headwind

Andrew Nicholas — William Blair — Analyst

Great. Thanks, John, and thanks, Efrain, those comments we’re super helpful. For my follow-up, I just wanted to ask a bigger picture question. You mentioned the HR Tech Conference in your press release and I think again in the prepared remarks. And I personally I was impressed by the number of vendors at the conference and the level of innovation, really across the sector. So with that in mind, given the number of new products, the amount of money that’s come into this space over the past several years. Just wondering if it’s changed how you kind of think about the build versus buy equation, does M&A make more sense today given the rate of change in the market and how rapidly new products are being built and gaining adoption? Just — essentially just want to get your thoughts on build versus buy appetite for M&A given all that’s going on right now? Thank you.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Yes, this is Marty, I’ll start it out. It’s an interesting question. I think the appetite is still there. I think valuations are still high, but we’ll see if they catch up and come down some and get more realistic. We’ve always been able to use M&A, not only for growth, from a kind of from a product perspective, but I mean actually adding to the technology, so time and attendance started with M&A back many years ago, now 10 or 11 years ago and probably 12 for the first time in attendance product, which would then we build into our product and now is one of the fastest growing products we have, from that perspective.

So, but I don’t — I don’t think so. I think we really look at that very closely, whether we can build. We have a very successful development team here, product management and development that kind of decide what do we have to do from a tech standpoint, we like it being bundled into the Flex product suite. And so we’re careful to do an M&A from a product add-on standpoint, and we don’t really see, I don’t really see — and John can comment on this too, a product that we’re missing right now in the sweet that I would have to go out and — that we would go out and look at from an M&A perspective. It’s more adding to what we have. The technology we feel, everything as John mentioned earlier, the HR, the HCM technology that we have, the combination with being able to do so much on the mobile. We have such a large use now of the mobile app.

We are also tying much more to the employees and self-service. And so, if you didn’t pick up on some of that at HR Tech, self service has become a big part of our model, that gets the employees of our clients more involved and right from just making their own changes, self onboarding, many aspects of when they sign up to Paychex pre-check which allows them to view, as you know, view their payroll before it’s processed. It’s really been important to bring the client employees into the picture, which builds better retention and better level of the Paychex mobile app, which still does a 4.8 out of 5 stars. And so, I don’t think there is a lot of M&A from a product need that we have to add to, but there is still a good appetite for M&A and we’re constantly evaluating opportunities.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yes, I would probably give you a good example that I actually talked about here on the call and one that’s — that we had previously announced and is in the works to go live. I think we’re constantly looking for the right combination of partnerships, technology we can build, and acquisition that we can build on, to kind of put a unified experience together that resonates with our customers and addresses, probably talked about the recruiting and applicant tracking and onboarding experience that we launched, re-integrated that, that’s really a combination of build. We got a partnership with Indeed, which we’ve talked about numerous times to help get candidates faster. And then it was also an acquisition that we made some time ago of a company on the onboarding and kind of applicant tracking side, and the unification of that into Flex and using the talent that we had bought, and that’s taken off tremendously. So it’s a better experience.

As Marty mentioned, already 1.7 million new hires have went through that process. So that’s an example. Another example that we’re currently in the process of and it goes back probably to your question on the insurance agency and about us working to really get more employees participating and all of our insurance products, and that was an acquisition that we made just a little bit ago with a benefits administration and enrollment technology, found a great small little company, it could add both the talent on how to design that from a user experience perspective, we’re in the final stages of deploying that and actually that will be deployed in our agency and our PEO as an electronic, mobile enabled way for employees to enroll in benefits and it’s also going to really highlight the ancillary benefits they get.

Again, this is then showing them the right plan, getting them to participate and getting them to really see the full suite of insurance we’ve got electronically and a unified experience. So that’s in early stages of being launched as we speak right now. So there’s a couple of examples of where I think we’re going to continue to look for experiences we’re trying to build for our clients and their employees. What capabilities do we have built in Flex today and where can we either find partners or find tech bolt-ons that will help us improve our experience.

Andrew Nicholas — William Blair — Analyst

Great. Thanks again.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Okay.

Operator

The next question comes from Ramsey El-Assal from Barclays.

Ramsey El-Assal — Barclays — Analyst

Hi, thank you for taking my question this morning. I wanted to ask about the pricing environment and the degree to which you’ve been able to kind of pass-through potentially larger price increases, given the inflationary backdrop, should we expect a bigger contribution from pricing in this environment this year than we normally would?

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yes, in terms of pricing, Ramsey, I think that — I think Marty mentioned last quarter’s call that we were towards the higher end of the range than of what we typically price and I think that’s where we’re at right now. And that’s what’s holding, look, I think, I think we are constantly trying to strive for getting the balance between price and value correct. And I think that we’re striking at this point the right balance on that issue.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Yes, the price realization feels very good right now, and as John mentioned, I think it was a combination of a lot of things. John is saying, so when you have that, a big need for recruiting, hiring and onboarding employees and we’re able to solve that particularly with technology, you’re saving — we’re hearing more and more from the clients that they’re saving operationally, they are being more effective, therefore a little bit higher on the price ranges is working and it’s sticking. So discounting has really been not an issue at all.

Ramsey El-Assal — Barclays — Analyst

Okay, quite helpful. A follow-up from me. I wanted to ask a question on sort of the relative resiliency of the two parts of your business. I’m just curious if there are drivers or factors that make Management Solutions and/or PEO sort of more cyclically sensitive relative to reach other. I kind of feel like investors have a better handle on Management Solutions as it’s the longer-dated segment. But I’m just curious if you feel that PEO also has the resiliency that you’d expect from the overall business?

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

I can start and John can jump in. I think, Ramsey, definitely PEO does right now all the things that John just talked about. I just mentioned recruiting, hiring, having insurance plans. That is a smaller mid-sized business you might not be able to have on your own. The PEO is continued to be pretty strong. You do see fluctuations. Like we mentioned in this first quarter, we didn’t have quite as much enrollment, but we’re also heading into the real selling season in the enrollment portion of the PEO. So, PEO has continued to be very popular, and I think it is very resilient in a time when I’m competing for employees — I’m a business competing for employees, and I need better insurance plans, I need better help in signing people up for those insurance plans. And so, yeah, I think it has very strong resiliency just like the Management Solutions offerings. Anything you want to add to that?

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

No, look, when I look at the clients that are attracted to the PEO value proposition, these are clients that have to navigate very complex HR or complex employment situations, multistate, they’re in difficult states where there’s a lot of regulatory compliance and other risks facing their business and they view our HR support, our compliance support, the way that we assist them in EEOC type of complaints and issues as a critical part of their business. I just got a comment on this from a client, a small client, they said they couldn’t live without their HR person helping them out. And I would step back and just again maybe reiterate macro because maybe we’re not explaining it well. You look at our employment — you look at the HR Pulse survey, and I look at what issues our nearly 700 HR consultants are facing for our clients, our clients are still trying to fill open positions. So not only did we see checks and worksite employees increase, but we continue to see them asking us for technology solutions support and how can they continue to fill open positions. So certainly, what we see in the underlying macro side in both the managed solutions and the PEO is that they’re really needing our HR support. It’s a complex environment, and I think there’s good resiliency going forward.

Ramsey El-Assal — Barclays — Analyst

Okay. So similar performance profile through the cycle for both segments is what I got from that, so I appreciate your answer. Thanks so much.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Sure.

Operator

Our next question comes from Eugene Simuni from MoffettNathanson.

Eugene Simuni — MoffettNathanson LLC — Analyst

Thank you. Hi, guys.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Hi, Eugene. I know that wasn’t your name.

Eugene Simuni — MoffettNathanson LLC — Analyst

No problem at all. So, I wanted to come back for a second to macro. I’m hearing loud and clear what you guys are saying that you’re not seeing any signs of recession, slowdown in the employment numbers and still very tight labor market. That’s clear. I wanted to ask about a slightly different metric, which is let’s say businesses’ willingness to invest in new technology, right. So situations where you would get real upgrades, feature additions, or maybe switching from a legacy provider to you guys things like that. I’m curious if you’re seeing any incremental caution across your small business customers on that even as performance remains strong as people just get more cautious looking ahead. And if not, then in your experience running this company for a long time when times get a little bit more volatile, can we expect that caution to increase and why not?

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

I would say at this point, we’re not seeing that yet because in fact in a time like this, they’re trying to — the biggest things when — John talked about some of the surveys we’ve been doing lately. It’s about operating efficiency. It’s about how do I fill these positions. So the demand is still there for their products at this stage of the macro. And so they’re needing people and they’re needing technology to save them money in other ways because wages are up, they have to do — they have to give more benefits. So they’re actually — I think in this environment, and it’s been this way as the market’s been tight, small and mid-sized businesses need to offer better benefits, they need to offer more technology, they need to have a mobile app like ours that you can deal with remote workforces. So actually, I don’t think that has — that there hasn’t — they haven’t gotten any more skittish I guess I’d say about investing. They actually really need it at this stage of the game.

And typically, depending on what kind of macroenvironment you’re in, but in this one where it’s about hiring and it’s about retaining employees, they’re very much looking for technology benefits, all the things we offer, and even if you’re a midsize and might have to go through some reshuffling of people, you’re looking to one of those 700 HR specialists that John mentioned that we have that would say, okay, how do I do this, how do I attract people, how do I retain them, how do I maybe lay some off, while I hire others in a little bit larger companies. So we’re actually seeing a great demand for technology in the HCM world as well as being able to handle remote workforces which really are here to stay.

Eugene Simuni — MoffettNathanson LLC — Analyst

Got it. Okay. Thank you. And then for my follow-up, probably a question for Efrain actually, switching gears a bit. We talked about the margin dynamics over the short term already a bit. So I understand there’s kind of ups and downs over the quarters. But I wanted to touch on the longer-term margin dynamics for a second. As we are now moving away from the COVID pandemic and settling more in maybe the steady state where digital channels have become bigger part of digital buying, has become a bigger part post-pandemic of your model. How are you seeing that really impacting structural margins of the business as we get more experience with that maybe more digital-focused model I’m curious?

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Well, Eugene, I think we talked about — certainly talked with many of you on the call. We have a relentless drive for efficiency in the business. And so as more of the business goes into either digitally-enabled solutions or fully-automated solutions, we expect overtime that’s going to be a driver of improved productivity and improved operating margins. So I’ve said — I always caveat with you also have to balance investment in the business for sustainable growth. So, if we get 50 basis points or 75 or 100 basis points of improvement in operating margins, we may decide, hey, that in order to create more operating efficiency — I’m sorry, more sustainable margins over the long haul, we have to invest a part of it. But certainly, there are very few weeks that don’t pass where we’re not having that conversation. I think that John’s been a big driver in the last decade around making that model work, and I expect that to continue over the cycle.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yeah, look, I’ll jump on that because I think — look our business model and our DNA as a company is around being the best operators in the business. I think we’ve proven that over decades, and that’s certainly not going to change with me in this position. And I think what you’re seeing is it goes back to the question you asked earlier is, look, clients are demanding technology because their employees are demanding technology. What we’re seeing relative to the digitalization is really not just us trying to push that on clients, there’s a big pull from clients and their employees to expect that they’re going to have a technology experience, whether that’s when they’re recruiting, if they want to recruit people, you’re not putting the ad in the paper. So if you’re doing that, you’re probably not going to find many people, particularly the people that are out looking for employment.

And so whether it’s benefits, whether it’s their finances, they’re looking for that to drive that. And not only is that a benefit for the customer, but that’s also a benefit for Paychex. So digitization continues with our mobile usage. It continues to accelerate with our clients and our employees. It’s up 67% year-over-year, and we had a pretty big year the year prior to that. So I continue to see this as being something — it’s not a nice-to-have anymore. It’s really a must-have if you want to go out and compete in the talent market today. You’ve got to have an HR technology solution that is easy to use and really meets the full needs of what employees are looking for.

Eugene Simuni — MoffettNathanson LLC — Analyst

Got it. Okay. Thank you very much.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Sure, Gene.

Operator

Our next question comes from Bryan Keane from Deutsche Bank.

Bryan Keane — Deutsche Bank AG — Analyst

Good morning. Wanted to ask about the different market segments. I know you guys called out strength in the midmarket. So just thinking about the health in the lower end of the market, could you just talk a little bit about new business starts, retention in that market, any kind of softness in spend you’re seeing there?

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Well, I think as we mentioned at the beginning, Bryan, the small business — new business starts are not as strong as they were last year, right? The last couple years during COVID and the pandemic, of course, we had a lot of people leave big business and start businesses. And so small business retention, from a client perspective, we said was starting to normalize a bit because some small businesses that started during that period have gone out of business.

But the demand for employees through — from small businesses is still needed. And we’re still — they’re still adding employees. So the good — I guess the bad news is some are a little bit more out of business, but the good news is that most of our clients, even at the small end, are adding employees and still have a lot of postings and openings to fill.

So I think that midmarket, I think we’re — what we’ve said about midmarket being stronger is I think we’ve executed much, much better in the midmarket, not only from a product suite and a technology suite of what we’re offering to the client, but the sales team has done really well. We hit our stride last year, and that has continued right through the first quarter with very good double-digit growth there.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yeah. And I would add that not only is the demand still strong in the midmarket, double-digit in the first quarter, I think, well positioned going forward. Retention, when you really look at that mid-market, which you get into our HR services, you get into the PEO, you get into the midmarket HCM, where our clients are getting the full value utilizing the technology, we’re seeing very good retention levels. As we said, our revenue retention is at record levels. I mentioned — I called out the PEO, particularly just on stellar performance in the first quarter relative to client retention, and we’ve seen strong retention in our HR businesses holistically, and the mid-market is solid as well. I also think that our price/value equation in that market has held up very, very well as well with our average sell-in revenue in the first quarter really strong. Really strong.

Bryan Keane — Deutsche Bank AG — Analyst

Got it. That’s helpful. And just one clarification for Efrain. On the second quarter margin, I heard about the second quarter revenue being lower, and you called out some call-outs there. But on the margin, in particular, is it just a revenue issue plus additional investments that just flow in that caused the drop in the margin? I just want to make sure I have all the pieces there for the 38% margin.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Bryan, you heard exactly what I said. So I must have been partially clear on that. So no, that’s exactly it. A little lower revenue, little higher expenses. It’s typically the lowest revenue quarter of the year, so you get a little bit of that impact. And it’s in line with what we anticipated it to be.

Bryan Keane — Deutsche Bank AG — Analyst

Okay, super. Thanks, guys.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Great.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Thanks.

Operator

Our next question comes from Kevin McVeigh from Credit Suisse.

Kevin McVeigh — Credit Suisse Group AG — Analyst

Great. Thanks so much.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Hi, Kevin.

Kevin McVeigh — Credit Suisse Group AG — Analyst

And my congratulations, and we share your view on Efrain, too, Marty.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

[Indecipherable] sometime and it’s astounding.

Kevin McVeigh — Credit Suisse Group AG — Analyst

Exactly. Hey, maybe just one, I guess, higher level. John, you’re taking the baton, the organization is super, super strong, but no two CEOs are the same. So any initial thoughts as to areas of focus, maybe where you might dial in a little bit more? Obviously, you’re building on a great legacy. But just any thoughts as to

Where your initial areas of focus are, whether it’s capital allocation or just technology, or just any initial thoughts?

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yeah. Well, Kevin, thanks for that. And as you know, I’ve been a part of the leadership team for nearly a decade now. So a lot of the things we’ve been working on I’ve been involved in and highly supportive of. So, look, I think you can expect we’re going to continue to really focus on expanding our leadership in technology and HR. I mentioned it earlier, we’re going to continue to be the best operators in the business, and we’re going to consistently be a top performer in terms of total shareholder return. I think these are three traditions I don’t plan to mess with, quite frankly, because they’re working and they’re what I believe.

Look, I think we’ve got — look, we’ve got opportunities to expand our offerings and continue to innovate and change. I would tell you that I think Paychex has always done that, but there’s no question under Marty’s leadership that has accelerated, and I think you should expect us to continue to accelerate that. We’re going to continue to look for new ways and growth platforms that we can apply to help our clients grow. We’re going to continue to invest in improving the experiences. I’ve mentioned that. I keep using this word experiences. We have a lot of great products. We have a lot of great service offerings. How we package those things together to address business problems is critical.

I think the other thing that we began to do more of and I think you’ll see more of is, look, we’re really beginning to use the large amount of internal data we have to really apply that to Retention Insights product that we’ve launched for our customers and being used with our HR professionals with the customers to identify how they can retain clients. We’re also using ERTC is a good example where we’re using our internal data sets to really identify customers that have specific needs and then able to get our salesforce into a situation where they can talk to a client who has that need at that moment, and that drives productivity. And I think you’re going to continue to see us do that. And I think you’re going to continue to see what I said before, we’re a tech company, and we’re going to continue to invest like a tech company. So I think relative to capital utilization, you’re going to continue to see us look at applying capital in areas where we can improve our technology footprint and help our clients.

Kevin McVeigh — Credit Suisse Group AG — Analyst

That’s super helpful. And then just one quick follow up. I think for you Efrain. I appreciate what you’re saying in terms of the outlook on the Fed funds, things like that. But can you tell us like what Fed fund rate is in the implied guidance right now? And then just remind us if you can what 25 basis points — like what the sensitivity is to the revenue for every incremental 25 bps?

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Yeah. So in the first quarter, we called it out, it was between three and four around the midpoint there where we expected. I think I may have called specifically 3.25%. So right now we’re working with something in that range. Obviously, everyone’s Chief Economist has a different number that ranges probably with a 4% and some probably are 5% and above. But I want to call out that — and so by the way, 0.25 basis point is somewhere in the $4 million to $5 million range in terms of net income. So it’s potentially important — it could be important. But, Kevin, the one thing I think that Jason pointed out that’s really important that I think what makes it a little bit trickier is you don’t want to push your chips to the middle of the table and go all in short term and have a great year in terms of year-over-year interest income only to give it back in the next year.

So what we’re really looking at is what’s the right duration for the portfolio in this environment. And so that’s why I wouldn’t necessarily, and I’m cautious about saying, hey, I got 100 basis points up versus my forecast, and that relates to X. I am a little bit cautious about that because I think we’ve got to manage a somewhat volatile interest rate environment here with the Fed and figure out what the implications for ’24 are. So I’ll just leave it at that. So we’re looking at it. And by the way, it’s not like somehow we’re geniuses here. We’ve got some of the best minds in the business on the fixed income side working for us. So we’ll take counsel and have a lot of discussion on that.

Kevin McVeigh — Credit Suisse Group AG — Analyst

Helpful. Thank you.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Sure.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Okay. Thanks.

Operator

Our next question comes from Samad Samana from Jefferies.

Jordan Boretz — Jefferies, LLC — Analyst

Hey, this is Jordan Boretz on for Samad. Martin, Efrain, congrats on the strong results. John, also congrats on the new role.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Thank you.

Jordan Boretz — Jefferies, LLC — Analyst

So I think we’ve touched on a lot already, but I wanted to double click on the employee growth that you’ve spoken about in both Management Solutions and PEO. So obviously with COVID, right, the recovery was not completely even by vertical or geographic area. I think in the past we called out Florida saw some strength first. So I’m curious the growth that you saw this past quarter, is that broad based or is it coming from a specific vertical or geographic area maybe lapping what we saw at the start of the recovery from the pandemic.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Yeah. So let me disaggregate. I’ll give some and then let John add some color commentary. So the PEO is a little bit different than Management Solutions per se. So what we saw was strength in ads in larger clients, and that’s partly a result of really good work that we have done over the last four to six quarters in mid-market. We’ve done good work before that, but I think you’ve seen the benefits of that. Coupled with, and that’s always important, coupled with, the improvement from last quarter in terms of the overall hiring environment in the first quarter. We expect that that starts to slow a bit.

With respect to PEO, when we look at worksite employees, that was pretty widespread. So obviously, because our business is over-indexed in Florida and in certain verticals relative to Management Solutions, we saw strength there. But PEO was pretty widespread. Now PEO is a little bit different in the sense that our average client is roughly about 30 or so employees. So you’re also getting a little bit of a larger, let’s call it, client effect in terms of the ads. So that’s a little bit more color. I don’t know if Marty, John, you want to comment.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

I think we’ve seen it across the board. Most of the client base has seen an increase in employees. So we’ve seen them adding employees and, of course, that’s going to be in that 1 to 20 range in particular, but 1 to 50 probably we’re seeing that. I think that Florida, the South, we’ve seen that in the Small Business Index and that those have been the strongest job growth states for small business because that’s where the people are. And so there’s still a lot of job openings, particularly in leisure and hospitality, and they’re able to fill them in the Texas, Florida, Georgia, even North Carolina areas, they’re their best job growth areas. So that’s where small businesses are doing the best. But, overall, we’ve seen — our business is able to add people and, obviously, then that’s adding checks, as John mentioned.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yeah. No, just to reiterate, I think we’ve seen across the board in pretty much all segments improvement in the employment levels and all the surveys we’re saying again, both the survey we did, I know there was one that I think that was just in a paper recently a couple days ago that I read that reinforced it. Small business owners are struggling more than midsized companies, and we’ve seen that in our data when we look at where are the number of checks and where are the worksite employees have accelerated more, a midmarket company that offers more benefits is outcompeting for the talent. And so that’s why we’ve really been focused on this recruiting and the partnerships that we’ve built and the technology we’ve built to help small business owners have a fair advantage.

I would also say, to Efrain’s point, another interesting in and again a little dated, but we certainly looked at this a lot when we were doing the downtrend. What we know is customers who were in our HR products, whether that’s our ASO product or PEO product, they decelerated less than the general market. And when it came time for the recovery, they were able to staff up faster. And I do think that’s because of our HR support. So we certainly in those areas have seen better recovery, faster recovery, more full employment. I think that has to do with both our technology and our advisory service and helping them [Indecipherable] advantage there.

Jordan Boretz — Jefferies, LLC — Analyst

Awesome. That’s all very helpful color. I think along those same lines, I wanted to follow up with, we’ve talked about how difficult hiring is at this time and your own business, you’ve seen this hiring pull forward and that’s obviously impacting the cadence of margins throughout the year. So this past quarter were your hiring plans on track, ahead of, or lagging your initial expectations? And was there any change in your ability to hire incremental sales or support staff throughout the quarter? Just curious if there are any changes on that end.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

No, actually, we did very well. The hiring machine really took off here from a recruiting and a hiring perspective, and retention is better. So, I think you’re hearing that in the overall market, particularly for larger businesses, now we made some changes to that. We improved some of our starting wage rates just like a lot of companies and did some other things as well for some of the existing employees. And I think that’s paid off. Yeah, we’re fully staffed, and we’re ready to go — actually we’re ready at the start of the quarter for sales and everything else. So we’ve done very well on the hiring front and are ready for the rest of the year, too.

Jordan Boretz — Jefferies, LLC — Analyst

Great. Well, thanks for taking my questions. Again, John, congrats on the new role.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Thanks.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Thank you.

Operator

Our next question comes from James Faucette from Morgan Stanley.

James Faucette — Morgan Stanley & Co., LLC — Analyst

Thank you very much, and my congratulations to both Marty and John as well. I wanted to — you’ve addressed a lot of our key questions, but wanted to quickly follow up. Marty, can you just talk to really quickly again the expected cadence for PEO during the course of the year? And just so I understand the expected improvement later, is that because of the things John mentioned of adjustments to the PEO plan, some changes in sales, etc., or is there something else that you expect to have an impact there?

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Hey, James, let me talk to that. So I think as I said at the beginning of the call, we started the year in the first half a little bit under what we expected from an attachment perspective and insurances were a little softer than we anticipated. The impact on margin was pretty insignificant. As we get through the year, our expectations are that the PEO growth accelerates in the back half of the year, and part of it is that we had pretty strong worksite employee growth coming out of the first quarter. So we — if you get that coupled with better healthcare attachment in the back half of the year, look, if people make decisions or making decisions in this quarter, you don’t see the revenue this quarter. You see it in future quarters. They’re making those decisions on the assumption that those things materialize, which they should, and growth accelerates in the back half of the year. That’s basically the explanation for what’s going on.

James Faucette — Morgan Stanley & Co., LLC — Analyst

Got it. That’s helpful. Thanks for the clarification there. And then I guess more from a landscape perspective, you’ve touched on and obviously highlighted over time, but also on this call, everything that you’ve done from a technology perspective in terms of Paychex’s ability to help its customers and continue to improve. But what are you seeing happening in the regional provider space? How are they being able to keep up with you, the incumbents, on tech? And do you expect further consolidation? Or I guess the real question is where you’re not winning from regionals, what’s the primary reason and how can you address that? Thanks.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, sure. Actually, we’re doing very well against the regionals. I think it is hard to keep up. They certainly have been viable competitors, but I think that we haven’t seen a big change in the competitive environment. I think, if anything, we feel like we’ve really continued to jumpstart. John mentioned the Voice Assist that we just offered, no one else has offered that with Google. The work we’ve done to combine for recruiting and onboarding their clients, I think the regionals — there may be some consolidation. I think they’re looking for probably some more support from a tech standpoint because there will continue to be a lot of investment going forward that we obviously you have a great track record of doing. But I think there’s been a lot of demand, so that’s kept everybody happy. The pie is — the overall pie has continued to grow, particularly in the midmarket. So I think they’ve all done — everybody’s done pretty well. We’ll have to see how that goes forward as we get to the back half of this year, but we feel very confident, not any big changes in the competitive environment, and we’ve performed very well.

James Faucette — Morgan Stanley & Co., LLC — Analyst

Great. Thanks a lot.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Okay. Thank you.

Operator

Our next question comes from Tien-Tsin Huang from JPMorgan.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Tien-Tsin?

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Might be on mute or may have dropped.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Gretchen, are you there?

Operator

Yes.

Tien-Tsin Huang — J.P. Morgan Securities, LLC — Analyst

I’m sorry, I’m here.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Yes, we can hear you now.

Tien-Tsin Huang — J.P. Morgan Securities, LLC — Analyst

I apologize. Had some trouble with my headphones. So sorry to keep you guys waiting. And quick thanks to Marty, of course. Always appreciated our conversation through the years, so not sure if you’ll miss these calls, but definitely we’ll miss chatting with you.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Oh definitely.

Tien-Tsin Huang — J.P. Morgan Securities, LLC — Analyst

Yeah, there you go. And John, look forward to working with you more. You did in your remarks credit Marty’s vision for embracing technology. And I think someone asked you about what your focus or legacy might be. I caught that, but I’m just curious, John, given your background on services and where you were before Paychex, I’m curious if you see more opportunity to improve services here further for Paychex to complement tech or is it one and the same in terms of tech and services starting to blend a little bit further. I’m just curious how you think about balancing those two things between the services and the tech of the company.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yeah. Look, Tien-Tsin, I think you’re right. I see it one and the same and that’s probably the reason why it’s here. Marty and I were reminiscing about my interview here and what really attracted me was Marty’s vision was very consistent with mine and my experience about where I saw our industry going from my prior experience. And my view is, I think, having the best technology and having a unified user experience is going to be critical not only for the demand of what customers’ employees want, but also to drive the operational efficiency that I think customers are going to want.

That being said, customers need to know how to use that tool and they are facing complex issues outside of items that technology can solve, particularly in the HR area. So I think we have a unique position to be able to reposition our traditional services, hey, I put something in a system for you. And really position that more as an advisory opportunity. And I think about the things we’re doing with the mass sets of data that we have, the benchmarking data, the way we can do analytics, the fact that we can call a client up and say we think you’re going to have a retention problem, let us walk you through your insights. That’s what service is going to be. It’s really not even service in the historical sense that you would see a service company talk about.

And I do believe that that’s going to resonate, and we see it resonating in this complex environment. More and more companies are going to end up having employees in multiple states than ever before to compete for talent and the remote workforce. That brings regulatory complexities that not just technology can solve for you. You’ve got to think about how you’re going to do this. And so I do think that we’re uniquely positioned, and I think you’ll continue to see us invest in technology and invest in HR and really position ourselves as the digital HR leader in the marketplace.

Tien-Tsin Huang — J.P. Morgan Securities, LLC — Analyst

Got it. No, I appreciate you going through that because I still think about it, when I started covering Paychex, I always thought of it as a services company and, of course, tech and digital has taken over everything. So just wanted to get back to basics there, so thanks for that. If you don’t mind my quick follow up, I know the calls getting long here. Just thinking about the modules and the breadth of services, you mentioned Paychex being the largest 401(k) recordkeeper. I know the equity markets have come down a little bit. Is that having any influence on your outlook in general? And also just clarifying, if you don’t mind two questions in one, just the healthcare enrollment, piece is the lower attach or enrollment a function of mix of clients or is it a competitiveness of the plans issue? I just want to make sure I understand that if you don’t mind those two questions. Thank you.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Well, you got two different ones in there.

Tien-Tsin Huang — J.P. Morgan Securities, LLC — Analyst

Sorry. Yeah, I’m trying to not take up too much time.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

I’ll talk to the first one. I’ll let John talk a little bit. Marty, if you want, on second. So, in our retirement services business, as many of you know, we do have something about a third of the revenue there is derived from a basis point. So it has a modest drag in terms of revenue. It’s not really significant. I’d just put it as de minimis in terms of the balance of the year. And then on healthcare enrollment, you were asking for more color on that, I’ll let John touch on what’s driving a little bit lower healthcare enrollment.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yeah. Look, I wish I had the perfect answer to that. Looking at all the data, my experience tells me a lot of that can be mix of clients. Again, a lot of it has to do what’s the average wage of a client, what’s the industries they’re in. You also have, as I said, economic situations where a person may be having benefits and deciding I can’t afford benefits right now given my economic situation. They drop the benefits. We recognize that. That’s why we’re doing a lot in really looking at our plan designs and the PEO in particular, rolling out lower cost plans, also rolling out nontraditional plans. We’ve actually created an entire wellness spectrum of products and services to really meet the needs of the economic needs of every type of worksite employee that we would have there. And we’re also driving digitalization into our H&B business. I mentioned that earlier. That’s rolling out in the second quarter, so that we can offer a more full suite of benefit options that can match the price point of both the clients and their employees regardless of what their economic situation is. So we certainly are trying to expand what we’re doing. We recognize that for some employees and some customers the cost of getting some of these benefits is outside of their capabilities right now, and so we’re really focused on product development perspective to make sure we have the broadest suite of offerings in the marketplace.

Tien-Tsin Huang — J.P. Morgan Securities, LLC — Analyst

Got it. No, that’s helpful. Thanks. And sorry for extending the call.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Oh no worries.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Thanks.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Your questions are always appreciated.

Tien-Tsin Huang — J.P. Morgan Securities, LLC — Analyst

Thanks for the time, guys.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Okay.

Operator

Our next question comes from Mark Marcon from Baird.

Mark Marcon — Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. — Analyst

Hey, good morning. Marty, congratulations on just tremendous accomplishments over the tenure that you’ve been the CEO. And John, look forward to working with you.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Thanks.

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Thanks.

Mark Marcon — Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. — Analyst

With regards to the macroenvironment, you did mention small business formations are a little bit lower. How are you thinking about the sales pipeline for HR Management Solutions? And to what extent can you dial the marketing strategy to highlight some of the tech improvements? I was at HR Tech. I was really impressed by the voice recognition program with Google. And are you charging more for those types of solutions? Yeah. We’re really — one, let’s take the marketing side of it. It’s doing exactly that, Mark. It’s being at HR Tech. It’s being — it’s getting the word out there. We’re doing a lot with — in trying to partner with folks like Google to be sure that it’s known that we have the only — we’re the only one that can do that with their Google Assistant and have you be able to do it totally hands-free. We’re pushing — the marketing has been pretty aggressive for years on — through webinars, through the tech conferences and, of course, through all the podcasts and then just all of the online work that we’ve done. And that’s been very important to us to get the message out, and we think that, that’s worked well. So I think that’s been good. I think on the — so we think there’s still a huge demand. And John mentioned, I think, earlier, the product penetration rates continue to go up. I think that as the tech word has gotten out there and the need, of course, as we’ve talked about a lot on the call, we’ve really seen this additional product penetration. And even if new business starts are less than what they were, they’re still up. They’re just not — they’re not up the big numbers that they were during COVID when everybody — or many people ran from large businesses and started small businesses. So they’re still up. We’re still, obviously, doing very well on the startups, but I think we’re doing even better with the product suite to make the additional penetration of the existing client base. Right. So the way I’m taking it, it sounds like the pipeline in terms of the key selling season for Management Solutions as well as PEO continues to be robust. And you’re not really seeing much of a change in terms of what we’re reading about from a macro headline perspective as it relates to that.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Correct. Correct. We still feel it should be a good selling season. It’s early, but we feel good about it.

Mark Marcon — Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. — Analyst

Right. And then can you talk a little bit about retention and how do you think that ends up being impacted as ERTC winds down? Does that have any impact?

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Hey, Mark. So, as we gave a little bit of color on that in Marty’s call, I think what I’d call out is two things: one is and it’s one thing that John mentioned. But from a revenue retention standpoint, we’re at near-record highs. So that makes sense. Marty called out on the very lower end, we’ve seen a little bit more churn. That is to be expected given where the market is right now. So on those two, I think we feel we’re pretty well positioned going into the balance of the year.

ERTC really should not have a significant impact on client retention. I think that it is a, if anything, is positive in the sense that it just demonstrates the value add of Paychex. A lot of our competitors are not talking about it because candidly their model doesn’t allow them to get there. Some are doing it, but I think that we think about giving our clients that level of consulting and expertise that John was mentioning earlier. So from a retention standpoint really should not have a significant impact.

Mark Marcon — Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. — Analyst

Terrific. Thank you.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Okay. Thanks, Mark.

Operator

The next question comes from Jay Meade [Phonetic] from Northcoast Research.

Jay Meade — Northcoast Research — Analyst

Good morning, gentlemen. And congrats on a great quarter. I just want to get some color around your float portfolio. And as the Fed continues to hike rates, do you think there will be any changes or has there been any changes in the management of your float portfolio?

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Hey. I think I answered earlier that in the environment, every time the Fed makes another pronouncement about what they expect to do, we huddle and figure out what the implications of the portfolio are. And what we’re trying to do is adjust the duration based on what we believe is going to happen and when we think we’re going to see peak interest rates to position the portfolio, not just for ’23 but for ’24. So we — I would say the changes would become a little bit more dynamic in terms of what the balance between short and long term is. And as the year progresses, we’ll continue to make adjustments real time to take advantage of what we think is our changes in the landscape.

Jay Meade — Northcoast Research — Analyst

All right. Thank you for re-answering that question. And do you have any thoughts on change in your return of capital to shareholders strategy?

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

There really — the short answer is no. We — and I think Marty and John talked a little bit about this, which is obviously, we’re going to continue to pay a pretty strong dividend. We will buy back shares to offset dilution. And we will look at deployment of capital in terms of M&A if it makes sense, if it builds value in the portfolio. So from that standpoint, no significant changes.

Jay Meade — Northcoast Research — Analyst

Thank you so much.

Efrain Rivera — Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Okay.

Operator

And our last question comes from Scott Wurtzel from Wolfe Research.

Scott Wurtzel — Wolfe Research, LLC — Analyst

Hey. Good morning, guys. Just one question from me. Just on the revenue retention side of things, I know you called out it’s still trending above pre-pandemic levels. And I think John had mentioned you’re continuing to see attach rates of high-value products. So just wondering if you can just maybe give a little bit more color on what products are exactly resonating most with the client base?

John Gibson — President and Chief Operating Officer

Yeah. It’s really our HR suite of products. You continue to see our online products. I just mentioned the retention — the recruiting and applicant tracking really popular right now, 401(k) retirement, very popular, and then time and attendance is the other. I put that in the online area. Anything around the automation of the employee-employer relationship is very high demand right now. People are looking for these operational efficiencies. Their workforces are more dispersed than ever before, and they’re leveraging technology to keep track of what’s going on.

Scott Wurtzel — Wolfe Research, LLC — Analyst

Got it. That’s helpful. Thank you, guys.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

Okay, thank you. Gretchen, that’s it, right, for the calls?

Operator

Yes, no further questions.

Martin Mucci — Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

All right. Well, one more thank you to the over 16,000 employees of Paychex who deliver the great results for us all. At this point, we’ll close the call. If you’re interested in replaying the webcast of this conference call, it will be archived for approximately 90 days. I would like to thank you all for your support you’ve given me in my role as CEO over the years, and I know I’m leaving you all in good hands. Have a great day. Thank you.

Operator

[Operator Closing Remarks]