Tyson Foods (NYSE: TSN) Q1 2020 Earnings Conference Call Transcript

Tyson Foods Inc  (NYSE: TSN) Q1 2020 Earnings Conference Call
Feb. 06, 2020

Call participants:

Jon Kathol — Vice President, Investor Relations

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Stewart F. Glendinning — Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer

Analysts:

Alexia Howard — Bernstein — Analyst

Ken Zaslow — Bank of Montreal — Analyst

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Heather L. Jones — Heather Jones Research — Analyst

Benjamin Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Adam Samuelson — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Ben Bienvenu — Stephens Inc — Analyst

Michael Piken — Cleveland Research — Analyst

Tom Palmer — JPMorgan — Analyst

Peter Galbo — Bank of America — Analyst

Jacob Nivasch — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Presentation:

Operator

Welcome to the Tyson Foods’ First Quarter 2020 Earnings Conference Call. All participants will be in a listen-only mode. [Operator Instructions] Please note this event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Jon Kathol, Vice President of Investor Relations. Please go ahead.

Jon Kathol — Vice President, Investor Relations

Good morning and welcome to the Tyson Foods Incorporated earnings conference call for the first quarter of fiscal 2020. On today’s call are, Noel White, Chief Executive Officer and Stewart Glendinning, our Chief Financial Officer. Slides accompanying today’s prepared remarks are available as a supplemental report in the resource center of the Tyson Investor website at ir.tyson.com.

Tyson Foods issued an earnings release this morning, which has been furnished to the SEC on Form 8-K and is available on our website at ir.tyson.com. Our remarks today include forward-looking statements as defined in the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These statements reflect current views with respect to future events such as Tyson’s outlook for future performance on sales, margin, earnings growth and various other aspects of its business. These statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from our expectations and projections. I encourage you to read the release issued earlier this morning and our filings with the SEC for a discussion of the risks that can affect our business.

I would like to remind everyone that this call is being recorded on Thursday, February 6 at 9:00 AM Eastern Time. A replay of today’s call will be available on our website approximately one hour after the conclusion of this call. This broadcast is the property of Tyson Foods and any redistribution, retransmission or rebroadcast of this call in any form without the expressed written consent of Tyson Foods is strictly prohibited.

Please note that our references to earnings per share, operating income and operating margin in today’s remarks are on an adjusted basis, unless otherwise noted. For reconciliations to our GAAP results, please refer to this morning’s press release. I’ll now turn the call over to Noel White.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Thanks, Jon and good morning everyone. Along with Stewart, joining us in the room today is Dean Banks, who joined the company at the beginning of the month and is beginning his transition to his new role as President of our company. Welcome, Dean.

We’re pleased to report, we delivered top and bottom line growth in our first quarter and generated record Beef results. Before I speak to these results, I’d like to talk about our focus on sustainability to meet the growing global demand for protein. That’s why recently announced at the World Economic Forum in Davos the creation of the Coalition for Global Protein, a combination of strategies and solutions including all forms of protein that are needed to responsibly feed a world population expected to reach almost 10 billion in 2050, requiring an estimated doubling of the production of protein needed today. Our goal is unite stakeholders across the food and agricultural sector to develop new and creative solutions to sustainably feed the world with affordable nutritious food. We believe this reflects positively on our strategy, which is focused on sustaining our company in our world for future generations, while growing our business by delivering superior value to consumers and customers and fueling our growth and returns through commercial, operational and financial excellence.

Turning to our results, our overall first quarter was in line with expectations with adjusted earnings of $1.66 per share. Beef and Pork results were strong, Prepared foods drove growth in retail consumption, Chicken improved operationally, although continue to face soft pricing which weighed on results. Looking across the marketplace, consumption of our retail Prepared food products has been outstanding. Both the Tyson core retail business lines, which were up more than 5% and total Tyson retail up more than 3% outpaced volume and sales growth versus the top-10 retail food manufacturers in the 52 weeks ending December 28. This growth contrasts with the total food and beverage category, which was down 0.4% for the same period.

We’ve now experienced six consecutive quarters of growth. Our core business lines are outpacing the categories with volume share growth of 1% and all core business fines are holding or growing share. In the foodservice channel, our foodservice-focused six product lines grew 3.5% at more than twice the total broad line distribution channel growth of 1.6% over the last 13 weeks. The power of our foodservice brands, innovation and capabilities across all channels has set the stage for growth. In the last three months, Jimmy Dean breakfast sausage volume grew 10%, Tyson Red Label grew 17%, and the Tyson brand grew 8%.

Now let’s take a look at our business segments. In Prepared Foods, growth in share performance has been outstanding, especially with our big brands. Retail innovation launched at the end of fiscal 2019 is performing well with velocities meeting or exceeding targets on our national launches of Jimmy Dean Biscuit Roll Ups and Jimmy Dean Morning Combos with both demonstrating velocity performance in the top half of the respective categories. While still early, Biscuit Roll Up show potential for driving category growth.

Prepared Foods profit margin in the first quarter was impacted by an $80 million increase in raw material costs, driven by Beef trim and Hams. Some of this increase was offset by pricing. Our Prepared Foods may continue to experience volatile input cost. We continue to experience some operational effects from our recent ERP system implementation, which impacted margins by roughly $40 million in the quarter. About half of this was discounted sales with the remainder related to inventory write-downs and donations. Although the effects have persisted longer than anticipated, we continue to work aggressively to resolve them and we are seeing progress.In the Alternative Protein category, the Raised and Rooted brands is only the beginning of our plan to build the world’s leading portfolio of plant protein products. In the back half of the year, we’re planning multiple new launches across protein forms, brands, meal occasions and channels. Over time, we see these options as another stable protein complementing our core offerings.

We’re being practical and thoughtful in our approach to enable us to create better product experiences with healthier nutritious ingredients at affordable prices. Looking ahead for the Prepared Foods segment, we expect to maintain our momentum in the market. We will do this by continued investment behind our brands through marketing, promotions and innovation. And we will remain agile with pricing to offset input costs, driven by the volatility of raw materials.

For the fiscal year, we believe the Prepared Foods segments adjusted operating margin would be 10% to 12%. Our Beef segment produced a record adjusted operating margin of 11.2% in the first quarter. The quality of domestic fed cattle has been excellent. This makes every link of the beef supply chain more valuable whether it’s a producer, the packer or the retailer and results in a better product for consumers.

Our premium programs continue to grow as a percentage of sales. Our customers and consumers are seeing the value and our quality and it’s translating into increased revenue. Our Fresh Meats premium programs have nearly doubled over the last five years to approximately GBP1 billion [Phonetic].

I’m pleased to report that our Finney County, Kansas plant damaged by fire last August is now back in full operations. Beef exports are strong, with the potential to be even stronger now that the trade agreements have been formalized. I’d like to remind you, however that our second quarter is typically our most challenging for beef. In addition to the challenges caused by winter weather in the Midwest, the drought in Australia has forced herd liquidation putting more beef on the global market.

Looking ahead, exports from Australia are expected to decline substantially as the ongoing drought and the tragic fires are likely to delay their herd rebuilding. With Australian beef amounting to a quarter of U.S. beef imports, this could be beneficial to our business. Our export sales continue to equal or exceed industry growth rates. In fiscal 2020, we’re expecting our beef segment’s adjusted operating margin to be at the upper end of 6.5% to 7.5%.

Moving to our Pork segment, strong pork demand and solid operational execution along with ample hog supplies led to a 14% adjusted operating margin in Q1. Export markets were the primary driver for increased demand. We believe that we are at the very early stages of the global demand shifts that we’ve expected from African swine fever. We’re filling additional orders to China and we’ve seen year-over-year increases of nearly 600% in the first quarter and we are already benefiting from indirect shipments as we backfill in other markets. We progressed towards a ractopamine-free hog supply. This will open up more markets to us as the need to move product globally increases. In fact, global demand for all proteins is increasing as ASF continues to reduce pork suppliers in Asia. For fiscal 2020, we’re expecting our pork segment’s adjusted operating margin to be 6% to 8%.

Now turning to the Chicken segment. We’re pleased that our execution is better and operations are on track to deliver $200 million year-over-year run rate improvement. However, pricing which has been weaker than expected, was a primary driver of our return on sales in Q1 where softer pricing has persisted into the second quarter. All leading indicators point to domestic poultry supply growth, the USDA is projecting a 4% increase in chicken production. As previously indicated, global protein supply is being impacted by ASF, while demand continues to grow at about 2% per year. In light of ASF, we anticipate global demand will keep pace with U.S. supply growth as Chinese imports of U.S. chicken are expected to double.

Domestically, we’ll continue to innovate and drive demand in the frozen value added space, with products like Tyson Air Fried Chicken. This product launched last July with strong customer acceptance is demonstrating dollar velocity performance in the top half of the category. Early data shows that the Tyson Air Fried Chicken is attracting new consumers and driving growth in this $2.6 billion category. Looking ahead in the chicken segment, we expect annual adjusted operating margin of 4% to 6% driven primarily by softer pricing and overall chicken supply.

In International and Other, both our legacy and newly acquired businesses are contributing to our improved international performance. We see the potential to expand in these growth markets, which are estimated to drive 98% of global protein demand increases over the next five years with 70% of that growth coming from Asia. We have a business of scale and there are still synergies to unlock. We have high quality assets and a strong team led by Chris Langholz, who recently joined the company as President of International. Chris has an extensive background at global protein and we welcome him to the Tyson team. Our legacy International businesses are performing well increasing sales and earnings. Our new acquisitions are providing great platforms for growth. We’re committed to becoming a global leader in protein by serving emerging markets and strategic customers across channels and across segments.

Across our businesses, trade deals are contributing to our optimism. We believe, with the improved access to global markets from recent trade deals, we are well positioned to capitalize on opportunities in the global marketplace. In addition to U.S. trade deals with Japan and South Korea, we’re very pleased the Phase 1 trade agreement with China and the U.S. MCA have both been signed. An important benefit of the deal with China is inclusion of more protein eligible for shipment. We’re shipping product to China and have more orders on the books. But keep in mind the tariffs that remain in place puts the U.S. at a pricing disadvantage in the Chinese market. If tariffs are lifted or reduced, we would likely see an acceleration of already increased global demand for U.S. pork, beef and chicken.

We’re closely monitoring news of the coronavirus. We’re actively assessing what this outbreak may mean for us, we’re a global business and preparing for the possibility of any impact. In China, we’ve been working with the government and have successfully restarted some of our operations. The financial impact is unknown at this time. With that, I’ll now ask Stewart to take us through the financials.

Stewart F. Glendinning — Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer

Thanks, Noel. And good morning everyone. Our first quarter results were in line with our expectations with earnings of $1.66 per share, up 5% from Q1 ’19. Operating income was $894 million, up 6% over last year. First quarter GAAP operating income was impacted $52 million or $0.11 per share for a restructuring charge and $16 million net of insurance proceeds or $0.03 per share for costs related to a fire at our beef plant in Finney County, Kansas.

Sales in Q1 were up 6% to just over $10.8 billion with an 8.3% return on sales. Sales volume was up 4.7% and average sales price was up 1.4%. Our operating cash flows were $894 million for the quarter and liquidity was $1.4 billion at quarter end. Including cash of $497 million, net debt was $11.2 billion and net debt to adjusted EBITDA was 2.7 times for the 12 months ending December 28. Net interest expense was $117 million in Q1. Capital expenditures were $312 million in the quarter and we continue to target an overall capex return of approximately twice our cost of capital.

Our capital allocation will continue to prioritize debt reduction, while reinvesting in our business for organic growth, buying back stock and increasing our dividend. In the first quarter, we repurchased 1.5 million shares for $132 million. Weighted average shares outstanding were approximately $367 million in the quarter. Our effective tax rate was 22.7% in the first quarter. Depreciation and amortization was $288 million. As Noel said, our newly acquired International businesses are contributing to the improvement in our international operations. Their contributions are in line with or better than our expectations, despite the high amortization and purchase price accounting loads placed on them.

Noel has articulated our segment return on sales guidance, which should give you an indication of how we expect our businesses to perform. Now I’d like to provide some additional commentary on our outlook. Keep in mind that fiscal 2020 is a 53 week year. However, we have adjusted our outlook to be comparable to 52 weeks. Net interest expense should approximate $450 million. We continue to project, approximately $1.3 billion in capex for the fiscal year as we progress with building additional processing capacity, for case ready fresh chicken, beef and pork and we plan to scale back capex when those projects are completed. We expect liquidity to remain above our $1 billion target. Our effective tax rate is expected to be around 23.5%.

I would like to remind you that Q2 is normally a weaker quarter for us and we have seen a slower than expected start in January. For Q2 fiscal year ’20, we are expecting lower earnings than Q1, driven by continued weak market conditions in chicken, higher raw material costs and some residual ERP impacts in Prepared Foods and normal seasonal cyclicality in beef and pork. When combined with the overall availability of protein, a continuation of these factors will likely result in our earnings being lower than the same quarter last year. This is before any potential impacts to our business from coronavirus.

Improvements in the back half are dependent upon achieving expected savings, and pricing improvements in chicken, managing to offset raw material cost increases in Prepared Foods and continued strong demand for beef and pork later in the year. That concludes my remarks and now we will go back to Noel for additional commentary. Noel?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Thank you, Stewart. Supply-demand dynamics have become much more global and our diversified business model and global footprint put us where the growth is occurring and allow us to capitalize on growth opportunities. In addition, we are encouraged by potential increased export demand and the resulting reduced domestic availability of proteins. In closing, our strong brand, strong team, world-class assets, great customers and a global footprint to meet growing demand for protein leave us well positioned for future success. That concludes our prepared remarks. Operator, we’re ready to begin Q&A.

Questions and Answers:

Operator

Thank you. [Operator Instructions] Our first question will come from Alexia Howard with Bernstein. Please go ahead.

Alexia Howard — Bernstein — Analyst

Good morning, everyone.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Good morning, Alexia.

Alexia Howard — Bernstein — Analyst

Hi, there. I’m sure others will be focusing on the chicken dynamics. But just to kick things off at a higher level, can you give us an update on where things stand with the trade agreements, particularly with China? What’s going on with the tariff situation and what are you seeing in terms of international shipments? Because I know that there’s things opening up around the world for you, how do you expect that to evolve over time? Thank you.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, Alexia, we are very pleased that our government has come to trade agreements just since our last conference call with Japan and Korea, Phase 1 agreement with China with U.S. MCA. So we’re very pleased with the progress that our government has made. Shipments continue and interest has been strong. We are currently shipping and we have more orders on the books for China and our business in the other countries that I mentioned, continue to be strong as well, not only those countries, but other countries around the world. So from a trade perspective, it looks very promising. And as you might have seen overnight, some of the tariffs that have been in place with China were lowered by approximately 5%. So that’s great progress as well.

Alexia Howard — Bernstein — Analyst

Great. And as a follow-up, we have seen the pork cutoff price start to increase over here as we would expect. We haven’t seen much movement in terms of the grocery on-shelf pricing which ultimately could start to drive the overall meat on the low part. Do you anticipate that those retail prices will start to increase on the pork side and then start to bleed out into the other parts of the business as well?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Alexia, first of all, I think pork continues to be a great value in the marketplace and whether it’s beef or chicken, chicken is also very attractively priced and whether there is room to raise prices on — I think it really depends on what happens with a cut out over the course of the next 60 days or so. I don’t think retailers are going to immediately going to change prices because of some short-term increases in wholesale prices. I think that if they believe that, that will continue to be the case, then they will. I think it’s too soon to call.

Alexia Howard — Bernstein — Analyst

Great, thank you very much. I’ll pass it on.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Very good. Thank you.

Operator

Our next question will come from Ken Zaslow with the Bank of Montreal. Please go ahead.

Ken Zaslow — Bank of Montreal — Analyst

Hey, good morning everyone.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Good morning, Ken.

Ken Zaslow — Bank of Montreal — Analyst

Just had two questions, one is, can you talk about your chicken operations outlook? the industry is clearly going as kind of soft, but can you parse out the difference between what happened Tyson internally issues and underlying fundamentals for the chicken industry and where is that going to go? Again, the quarter is done, the second quarter is largely kind of in the books as well. But can you talk about where the outlook will go and how you kind of think about that?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Sure, Ken. First of all, our chicken operations, if you remember last quarter I said that we expected a $200 million improvement year-over-year in ’20 versus 2019, clearly from a performance standpoint, and I am pleased to say that we are on track for the run rate of capturing that $200 million. So our plants continue to perform better than what they were, however, the pricing environment on poultry has been relatively weak and that’s obvious and publicly available data. So the improvements that we’ve captured purely from a performance standpoint has been either offset or more than offset by the weakness in wholesale pricing.

Ken Zaslow — Bank of Montreal — Analyst

So, you think it’s mostly the industry, not your operations that has created the downside to your guidance?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Absolutely, yes.

Ken Zaslow — Bank of Montreal — Analyst

Then, my second question is just building on last year’s question is, when I think about the exports, can you tell me when do you think the exports will increase for chicken, beef and pork in 2020 and more importantly 20121? Are we looking at double-digit increases across the board? Are we looking at 20%? Like how do you think about this in terms of how the export picture will build over the next — for each of the proteins?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Ken, I can’t give you an exact number as to what the expectation of the increase is going to be. I think it will certainly increase and if we think back through 2019, there was a run-up in hog prices in the spring and exports didn’t material quite as quickly as what was expected. There were heavy shipments coming out of South America and Europe to China. And then — and then the Chinese stepped in into the U.S. market, and we saw the effect of that in the fall and a lot of the product arrived and cleared in time for the Chinese New Year.

There is product that continues to shift, there continues to be interest in pork and the same thing would be true with beef and with poultry. So interest has been strong, demand has been good and the other thing I mentioned on the call last quarter, is that we expected to backfill into other markets and that in fact has happened. Our shipments to some of the other countries have in fact increased. So it’s not just China, it’s to other countries around the world as well.

Ken Zaslow — Bank of Montreal — Analyst

Thank you.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. Thank you.

Operator

Our next question will come from Rob Moskow with Credit Suisse. Please go ahead.

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Hi, thank you. I had some questions about the chicken guidance, you lowered the margin estimate by about 200 basis points, but also in your prepared remarks, Noel, you said that you’re now including the assumption that global demand will match the supply growth, which has also been increased to 4%. I think in your prior guidance, you said you were not going to include any ASF impact on the chicken business or on the business as a whole. Are we now assuming that there is an ASF — a positive ASF impact in the back half of your year? And then I had a follow-up.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yes, we do think that there will be a positive impact, Rob on exports. We are expecting the 4% production increase. We are expecting continued to see growth in demand from an export standpoint, not only to China, but to other places in the world as well.

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Okay. But it’s just not enough to drive your overall chicken pricing higher to offset the excess supply here in the U.S.?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yes. And Rob, I think we need to keep in mind that when we talk about exports and into the different markets that there is strength in certain products, there’s weaknesses in certain products when we talk about chicken. The USDA data would indicate that chicken breast pricing in particular has been — has been weak. On the other hand, there has been strength in other products such as boneless, skinless, thighs, tenders and wings. So it’s not as simple as just thinking chicken but it’s specific parts that there’s strength and weaknesses.

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Sure. And here’s the follow-up. The — I’ve talked to industry participants about what’s causing the excess supply, it looks like some of it’s transitory related to favorable weather and grow-out. Can you give us a sense as to whether you think this 4% U.S. supply growth sustains for another year, for another two years? I mean I could make the case that there is a lot of capacity coming online. So maybe 4% is the new number, but I could also see the argument that maybe we’re coming to the end of a multi-year expansion in the industry.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Right. Rob, first of all, there was — there was very favorable weather conditions as we came through fall for growing conditions. I think the weight of the chicken as an industry was up year-over-year. I know that ours was — was certainly heavier, heavier than what we originally projected, and I just have to assume that that’s probably the case with others in the industry as well. Historically, the U.S. increase over the course of time has averaged at about a 2% growth rate, and that’s pretty well kept pace with what the increase in demand has been, so over the course of 12 months, it’s hard for me to say, but I think over the course of time and if we think in terms of about 2%, that that’s going to where my mindset would be.

Robert Moskow — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Okay, all right, thank you.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, thank you.

Operator

Our next question will come from Heather Jones with Heather Jones Research. Please go ahead.

Heather L. Jones — Heather Jones Research — Analyst

Good morning, thanks for taking the question.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Good morning.

Heather L. Jones — Heather Jones Research — Analyst

Good morning. So I want to stick with — stick with chicken and just dive a little deeper. You mentioned that you are on pace to generate the $200 million in operational improvements and like you said breast meat pricing has been weak. Now if we rewind a few years ago, Tyson was always, well, pretty consistently short breast meat but it seems like the year-on-year deterioration in Tyson’s chicken performance for this quarter was worse than the industry. So am I right in thinking that you guys are long more breast meat than you’ve been in the last couple of years? And if so, is there any expectation that that should shift in coming quarters?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Good question, Heather. When Rob asked a question about production increases and I mentioned that the weights were heavier than expected. That is in fact true with us and breast meat production as well. So we did use more internally, we did not buy as much on the outside market as what we had originally projected or planned to. Corrections have been made, Heather. Our buy versus growth strategy remains intact. However, in Q1 it was not exactly as we planned.

Heather L. Jones — Heather Jones Research — Analyst

Okay, thank you for that. And my follow-up is, as far as, how should we think about, I mean, pork exports to China have been pretty strong consistently and I would expect those to accelerate, but on the poultry side, it — just wondering if you could give us a sense of how you expect the cadence of those exports to be. The coronavirus seems to have slowed down the logistics some, but do you expect this to build as that February 14 agreement takes place or I mean how should we — how are you guys thinking about the cadence and exports to China, poultry specifically?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Heather, every day brings something new. The news overnight was welcome. If anything, I would say that we’re going to have quite a bit of volatility. As I mentioned, demand continues to be — or interest at least continues to be strong. There is certainly the need and coronavirus has just clouded that, frankly, Heather. There has been disruptions. There has been disruptions in domestic production, there has been disruption at the ports. So that has skewed shipments, receivables. I would expect that — we get — once we we get past the coronavirus incident, whenever that might be, I do think that there is going to be very strong demand coming out of that, but trying to estimate what that time period is going to be is not possible at this point.

Heather L. Jones — Heather Jones Research — Analyst

Okay, thank you so much.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Thank you.

Operator

Our next question will come from Ben Theurer with Barclays. Please go ahead.

Benjamin Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Yeah, good morning, Noel and Stewart. Thanks for taking my question. So I guess we’ve talked a lot about chicken. So I want to switch a little bit into pork and beef. So clearly on pork to start off, I mean you’ve had a very strong first quarter, 14% operating income margin, but nonetheless, you kept the guidance unchanged at 6 to 8. So I mean simple arithmetic, it looks like you’re looking for a relative weakness on a sequential basis for the remainder of the year and also curious, because you’ve said on an earlier question that you now do take a little bit of ASF benefit into the back half for the chicken segment. So you’re not taking anything into consideration for pork or is it just trying to be conservative. If you could give a little more clarity on the guidance in pork.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Sure. Ben, you know, our Q1 October, November, December is typically the strongest margin quarter for us and it’s not unusual for us to drop off in Q2. So we’re basically following the typical seasonal patterns that we would see and normally, we will see things start to improve in Q2 and then through the summer, it’s not bad. And then in Q1, October, November, December, it strengthens pretty substantially. So we’re just projecting the basic seasonal patterns that we’ve seen in the past.

Benjamin Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

And that is literally absent any ASF benefit, though.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

In this case, yes.

Benjamin Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Okay. And then on beef, I mean, clearly you’ve highlighted it within the release that you still had obviously the operational headwind, but just not being able to get enough volume through because of the closing of the Kansas plant and the fire that affected it, now you’re back in. Could you elaborate a little bit like, if things would have been normal, how would’ve beef turned out? So if you, I mean you’ve adjusted for it to a certain degree, but how would your volume — how is your volume at the other beef plants during the quarter where you printed the minus 8% if we take out the one that was shut down because of the fire. So just to see the underlying fundamentals on beef.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. Ben, it’s impossible to say what volumes would have been without the fire. I think — I think the distinction was basically the strength in our export demand and I think it’s more of a demand story than restricted supply story. So don’t know what supply would have been without the fire. But I do know the demand has been extraordinarily strong both domestically and from an export standpoint of view.

Benjamin Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Okay, perfect. I’ll leave it here. Thank you very much. Get back into queue.

Operator

Our next question will come from Adam Samuelson with Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead.

Adam Samuelson — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Yes, thanks, good morning everyone.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Good morning.

Adam Samuelson — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

So I was hoping to just dig a little bit more on the chicken business and really just make sure or just think about the different market segments there and the pricing and market pressure that you’re facing, I mean, again I think it’s going back to Heather’s question on the buy versus grow and breast meat seems to be bearing a disproportionate amount of some of the market pressures of late. And just trying to think about how that’s translating into your — whether it’s the tray pack, the small bird, your further process business, I wouldn’t think that that impact is equal. I mean especially where I would think leg quarters, you should have some benefit from better pricing and as we think about 2020, just any comments on contracting for various foodservice institutional accounts, how that — how those played out?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. Adam, first of all, I can’t talk about pricing, it’s a very sensitive subject. Most of the pricing is concluded, not all of it, but most of it. And I would say that as we came through our Q1, and as we entered Q2, breast meat pricing in particular is weaker than I would have expected it to be. However, as I mentioned earlier, there has been strength in other products. Leg quarter pricing, frankly has been a bit erratic as we came through Q1, January, February, and don’t know at this point what March, April, May is going to hold. A lot of those prices are not yet settled. So that would be purely speculative on my behalf. However, with breast meat, USDA data would say it’s trading something below $1 right now. So it’s at or near historic lows. It presents a tremendous value, both at retail and at foodservice and typically when that happens, you see some type of increase in either featuring or promotions at foodservice establishments. So, I think that over the course of time, and whether that’s a month or six months, we’re going to see increased promotion on those proteins that have the greatest value and right now that would include chicken breast.

Adam Samuelson — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Okay and then just shifting gears, a bit of a clarification question, but maybe there is something in here just in the quarter in Prepared Foods, your reported volume was down 3.1%. You look at whether the scan Nielsen data that we can track and what you report in the slides in terms of the growth, both for retail and focus by foodservice items, there is growth, and I am just trying to understand kind of the disparity between the reported segment growth on the volume side versus what you can see in the measured channels.

Stewart F. Glendinning — Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer

Yeah. I think when you look at the — this is Stewart. When you look at the reported volumes, those volumes reflect some channel shifts that we had between our segments. They don’t account really for any profit and on a total basis are pretty immaterial. You see them in the quarter because of the kind of product. But the numbers we are giving you in terms of the performance in the market are more of the organic numbers that reflect the momentum of the business.

Adam Samuelson — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Okay, all right. I appreciate that color. I’ll pass it on. Thanks.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. Thank you.

Operator

Our next question comes from Ben Bienvenu with Stephens Inc. Please go ahead.

Ben Bienvenu — Stephens Inc — Analyst

Hey, good morning. Thanks for taking the question.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Good morning, Ben.

Ben Bienvenu — Stephens Inc — Analyst

I wanted to ask about SAP. Stewart you had said that — I appreciate the color on the call out to the impact to Prepared Food in the quarter, obviously you guys are making strides on improving the margins, net raw material costs and net of SAP cost challenges and the guidance for the balance of the year suggest that, that should continue, margin expansion. So I’m just curious if you could provide any color on how you expect the cadence of SAP impact the linger, if at all. Should we see the magnitude diminish? And is it impacting any of the other segments beyond Prepared Foods?

Stewart F. Glendinning — Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer

Well, just to be clear, this is a system that was implemented for both Chicken and Prepared. We see the impact only in Prepared at the moment. We don’t want to give any specific guidance on the timing for that. Know that we are working aggressively, we are managing the factors that influenced the write-offs in the distressed inventory that we see and we, of course, expect to see an improvement as we move forward.

Ben Bienvenu — Stephens Inc — Analyst

Okay, great and then one question for me on on the Chicken segment, you talked about Noel making some corrections to being a bit longer on boneless skinless breast. Is that — can you help us think about what those adjustments are, how quickly you can make them? And I guess this is a sensitive question, I understand, but I think on the facility front, you guys had been looking at opening the Humboldt facility later this year. Does the current supply environment impact that decision or the timing of that at all to the extent you can comment?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

You’re right, Ben. That is a sensitive question. No, the production in our Q1, it was heavier than it was originally projected, and we, as always, respond to things that we don’t expect. So you can fully expect that to take place, and as far as timing of the Humboldt start, no, nothing has changed with that. The project is on schedule and on budget.

Stewart F. Glendinning — Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer

And one other things — sorry, Noel. If I can just go back to the previous question, I just want to make sure that I’m very clear. Ben, your question on when we expect to see improvement. We have so far this quarter seen run rates that have been consistent with last quarter. And just so — just for clarity, as we have — as we’re working on this, of course, we expect this not to be a permanent part of our business. I want to be really clear that, that improvement lies in front of us.

Ben Bienvenu — Stephens Inc — Analyst

Very, very helpful. Thanks and best of luck.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Thank you.

Operator

Our next question will come from Michael Piken with Cleveland Research. Please go ahead.

Michael Piken — Cleveland Research — Analyst

Thank you. Just wanted to touch base a little bit on some of the chicken sandwich wars and basically it seems like there’s been a lot of talk about the success of those sandwich wars and just wondering like, is the dynamic within the chicken markets healthier maybe for like some of the smaller birds and maybe the tray pack or are there — is there a spillover effect from the weakness maybe in some of the bigger bird breast meat markets? And can these sandwich wars maybe help the chicken market? How much?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Michael, you know, with fast food, different — different customers use different size birds so it’s not possible to say that’s advantaging one segment versus another. If we go back a couple of years ago we saw hamburgers being heavily promoted and obviously this last year, that switched to chicken burgers and chicken sandwiches. And it looks like this year that we’re going to see the same thing and that’s purely because of the value that chicken is right now. And ground pork and beef prices are higher, lean beef, particularly lean, imported beef is up substantially due to the reasons I talked about in the script with drought conditions and the shortage of supply coming on the imported side.

Michael Piken — Cleveland Research — Analyst

Okay. Yeah. And then I guess just as a follow-up here. I think one particularly large operator you guys serviced pretty heavily is talking about potentially doing pretty big promotion for chicken later this year. Like, is it possible or what steps would take place like if there is not enough of like the smaller birds like can you guys chop up some of the bigger breast meat? Are there some heavier birds to accommodate that product or how easy is it to do it? What steps does that entail? Thank you.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Well, okay. Mike, first of all I cannot talk about what specific customers may or may not be doing, but I think that there will be sufficient supply regardless on whatever customers that you might be referring to. So I don’t see an issue from a supply standpoint but can’t talk specifically about any specific customer.

Michael Piken — Cleveland Research — Analyst

Okay, thank you.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, thank you.

Operator

Our next question will come from Ken Goldman with JPMorgan. Please go ahead.

Tom Palmer — JPMorgan — Analyst

Good morning. It’s Tom Palmer on for Ken. Thanks for the question. I first wanted to clarify the chicken guidance. Company is guiding to 4% to 6% EBIT margin absent additional impacts from ASF. The prepared remarks and a lot of the answers today seem to focus on when pricing should get better this year from increased ASF driven exports. So, just given the first quarter results, which sounds like a slow start to the second quarter, What are the non-ASF drivers that would get the segment to 4% to 6%?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. Well, first, typically as we go into Q3 and Q4, our Q3, Q4, we do see seasonal improvements that take place. So as I talked about pork, same thing is true with chicken that once we get into a little warmer weather, people fire up their grills, demand does increase. So we’re projecting typical seasonal strength in chicken, as well.

Tom Palmer — JPMorgan — Analyst

Okay. I mean the quick math is if you’re running at 2.5%, you’d be north of 5.5% in kind of the second half, I guess?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

If that’s what the math says, I guess that’s what it would say.

Tom Palmer — JPMorgan — Analyst

Okay. And then, just wanted to ask on the beef side. I mean it’s not a huge cut, but you did lower supply expectations. Is this mainly related to end of the year? What you’re seeing in terms of some of the cattle inventory and do you think we would actually exit the fiscal year with year-over-year declines in supply or flattish? Just trying to get the picture there. Thanks.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. Tom, cattle supply is basically flat year-over-year. Cattle and feeder are actually up some but month-to-month, quarter-to-quarter, it does impact pricing and availability, but through the course of the year, it all evens out. So as we look at the balance of 2020, basically flat, if not slight increase over 2019. Same thing would be true in 2021 that we look at the calf crop and it would say that we will have equal, if not slightly greater number in 2020 and then, basically flat into 2021. And then as we move into 2022 and 2023, it really depends on retention rate of peppers, and other factors that we closely monitor. So to answer your question, it’d be basically flat supplies, perhaps a slight increase in 2020.

Tom Palmer — JPMorgan — Analyst

Okay, thanks.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, thank you.

Operator

Our next question will come from Peter Galbo with Bank of America. Please go ahead.

Peter Galbo — Bank of America — Analyst

Hey, guys. Thank you for taking the question. Noel, I just wanted to get your thoughts kind of from a much higher level as it pertains to coronavirus and maybe some of the more medium to longer-term impacts. Have you guys done anything, any work or just around if wet markets in China are curved here over the next several months? Just what has that meant historically in terms of the Chinese consumer turning to more of a grocery store? And does that benefit the import market more than, say, it would if consumers were at the wet markets?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yes, you’re right. I think — I think, if anything, it’s just going to accelerate the efforts that the Chinese have had to decrease the number of wet markets. I think that will continue to see modern grocery continue to grow in China, so it’s an acceleration. I think both ASF and coronavirus will contribute to that. Short term, obviously there is going to be some impact from coronavirus. But that — that will pass. So we think that on a much longer term basis that how we will service modern retail in China and over the course of relatively short period of time we think that, that will probably take place, particularly with the initiatives that the government has in place.

Peter Galbo — Bank of America — Analyst

Got it. Okay, that’s helpful. And Stewart, maybe just a quick clarification on the Prepared Food side. With — and I know this was asked earlier but just with the volumes down, and I think you mentioned some of it was kind of inter-segment changes, I mean without any profit impact, is that something we should kind of continue to expect over the course of the year that, that volume might just optically look negative because of the segment change?

Stewart F. Glendinning — Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer

No. In fact, you’ll only see it in this quarter. Last year, really this took place a year ago. And because of the seasonality of this product, you see a little bit more impact in the quarter. As I said, in total, the volume is not material. And certainly the profit is completely immaterial.

Peter Galbo — Bank of America — Analyst

So on a go-forward basis, we would expect to kind of see that Nielsen and then the data that you guys kind of converge a little bit more with reported results.

Stewart F. Glendinning — Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer

Yeah, that’s correct. I mean, you also need to bear in mind that the various Nielsen numbers and the foodservice numbers that some of those represent a portion of the volume and certainly, Jon can provide a little bit of a reconciliation during for the follow-up call.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Peter, I think the takeaway needs to be that I mentioned that our core lines grew something a little greater than 6%. We captured at least 1% additional share points and the numbers are just clouded by this production that moved from one segment to the other. So overall, our retail business continue to be extraordinarily strong.

Peter Galbo — Bank of America — Analyst

Got it. Thank you, guys.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, Thank you.

Operator

Our next question is a follow-up from Heather Jones with Heather Jones Research. Please go ahead.

Heather L. Jones — Heather Jones Research — Analyst

Thanks for taking the follow-up. So, Noel, just to clarify a comment you just made a few minutes ago. So the closure of the live markets that we’ve seen in some provinces in China, are you saying that you expect China’s ongoing shift away from live markets wildlife trade separate to more like grocery channels? Are you saying you expect that shift to happen? You mentioned something over the short term, are you expecting that shift to happen over the short term, you said?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

No, what I — what I said is that I thought that the shift moving from wet markets to modern retail, the combination of ASF and coronavirus would expedite that transition.

Heather L. Jones — Heather Jones Research — Analyst

Okay, okay. And my other follow-up is just going back to your comments earlier about the outlook for beef as far as what’s going on in Australia, global demand. So it sounds like you have a bullish view on beef trim cost. So could you speak to what your expectations are for chicken feature at retail, not asking about any specific customers, but just in general, is it your expectation that chicken feature will benefit from these trim costs this year?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

The short answer would be yes. I think that when we look at value between the proteins, chicken has a — particularly chicken breast right now is in fact a tremendous value. And Pork, is frankly as well, with the quantity of pork that’s being generated. Despite the fact that, exports are up, and ground beef attributable to the increase of imported lean is relatively high priced compared to the alternatives. So I would expect to see more features of chicken as we move into spring and summer.

Heather L. Jones — Heather Jones Research — Analyst

Okay, awesome. Thank you so much.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Thank you.

Operator

Our next question is a follow up from Rob Moskow with Credit Suisse. Please go ahead.

Jacob Nivasch — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Hi, thank you. This is Jake Nivasch on for Rob. Thanks for the follow-up. Just a quick one. Is there any reason why you guys didn’t confirm the EPS guidance that set from last call?

Stewart F. Glendinning — Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer

Jake, we didn’t give any EPS guidance on the last call and we’re not planning to give EPS guidance for this year.

Jacob Nivasch — Credit Suisse — Analyst

On the press release, though, didn’t you guys say high single-digit growth?

Stewart F. Glendinning — Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer

No, we did not. We’ve talked about what our our long term algorithm look like, but we did not address specifically anything for 2020.

Jacob Nivasch — Credit Suisse — Analyst

Got it, okay. Thank you.

Operator

Our next question is from Ben Theurer with Barclays. Please go ahead.

Benjamin Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Yeah. Good morning, again. I just wanted to follow up on Prepared Foods. So you made very clear during your call, you had obviously some cost associated because of the European implementation that you adjusted for, but you’ve also mentioned the $80 million headwind due to beef trim and ham, so I was looking up at least so far what the quarter runs compared to last year and it seems still there is a fairly significant headwind in terms of ham cost which clearly would result — would kind of drive towards a relatively weakness because of that cost for Prepared Foods, but then benefit on pork. So what is your expectation, I mean within that broader concept for that you internal COGS on beef and ham, and how that should turn out through the year with or without ASF just to understand a little bit the dynamics on the margin recovery on Prepared Foods, where this is coming from.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Sure, Ben. Yeah, I can address that. And there was a spike in prices of both 90% lean beef as well as enhanced, and we — we do not intend to take pricing action unless we believe that there is a shift that’s taking place in pricing. As you look at ham pricing as we entered the fall, they presented pretty good value and they moved counter-seasonally higher to about $0.90 on the volume basis. And subsequent to that they’ve come back down, in fact, fairly sharply, most recently or at least in the last couple of weeks. And that is opposed to imported lean beef and if we do believe that there is a longer-term shift in pricing, that’s when we would take pricing action, but we typically do not take pricing action on what we believe could be a short-term impact. And it doesn’t matter if it’s hams or it’s pork bellies, or bacon or trim, only if we think that, that shift is taking place and expect that to continue.

Benjamin Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Okay. So in other words, if it were to persist a little longer or come back, you would start thinking of price increases, which would still take some time to offset, so you modelize like potentially would not get to your margin on Prepared Foods somewhere between 10% to 12%, but then you should more than offset that with better margins within beef and pork, or you’re likely going to be above what the current guidance is. Is that fair to assume?

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

I think that’s a fair assessment, Ben.

Benjamin Theurer — Barclays — Analyst

Okay, thank you very much.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Thank you.

Operator

This concludes our question and answer session. I would now like to turn the conference back over to Mr. Noel White for any closing remarks.

Noel White — Chief Executive Officer

Well, thank you for your time today and please join us online for Annual Meeting of Shareholders which starts at 11 o’clock. Eastern Time. Thank you.

Operator

[Operator Closing Remarks]